Bhardwaj B K, Kacker S K
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, All Indian Institute of Medical Sciences, Ansari Nagar, New Delhi.
J Laryngol Otol. 1988 Jan;102(1):20-4. doi: 10.1017/s0022215100103858.
The records of 120 patients who had undergone revision stapedectomy were analyzed to determine: (i) the causes of failure; (ii) how to prevent failure by taking precautions during primary surgery; (iii) hearing results; and (iv) possible identifying factors which might pinpoint those patients with a high risk of sensorineural deafness. A review of these cases demonstrates that the results of revision stapedectomy are different from those of primary stapedectomy. The commonest cause of failure was prosthetic dislocation (30.8 per cent), followed by fibrous adhesions (18.3 per cent) and otosclerotic regrowth (14.1 per cent). First revision operations resulted in post-operative bone-air gaps of 15 dB. or less in 46.5 per cent of cases, much better than 25 per cent for second revisions. Primary stapedectomy resulted in successful closure of the air-bone gap to 15 dB. or less in 89.5 per cent of cases. The sensorineural loss occurred in 11.3 per cent or first revisions and in 16.6 per cent of second revisions, as compared to 1.3 per cent after primary surgery. 'Dead ears' were encountered in 2.2 per cent of first revisions, as compared to nil in the primary group.
对120例行镫骨切除术翻修术的患者记录进行分析,以确定:(i)失败原因;(ii)如何在初次手术期间采取预防措施以防止失败;(iii)听力结果;以及(iv)可能的识别因素,这些因素可能确定那些有感音神经性耳聋高风险的患者。对这些病例的回顾表明,镫骨切除术翻修术的结果与初次镫骨切除术不同。最常见的失败原因是假体脱位(30.8%),其次是纤维粘连(18.3%)和耳硬化再生(14.1%)。初次翻修手术在46.5%的病例中术后骨导-气导间隙为15dB或更小,远优于二次翻修的25%。初次镫骨切除术在89.5%的病例中成功将气骨导间隙缩小至15dB或更小。感音神经性听力损失在初次翻修术中发生率为11.3%,二次翻修术中为16.6%,而初次手术后为1.3%。初次翻修术中2.2%出现“全聋”,而初次手术组未出现。