Scher H I, Yagoda A, Herr H W, Sternberg C N, Bosl G, Morse M J, Sogani P C, Watson R C, Dershaw D D, Reuter V
Department of Medicine, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York 10021.
J Urol. 1988 Mar;139(3):470-4. doi: 10.1016/s0022-5347(17)42495-5.
Of 50 patients with bladder cancer given 1 to 5 cycles of neoadjuvant methotrexate, vinblastine, doxorubicin and cisplatin in a pilot phase I and II study 63 per cent of 41 with pure transitional cell stage T2-4 lesions responded. While significant downstaging occurred by transurethral resection of the bladder in 70 per cent and by cytology in 60 per cent of the patients, the final T response rate by all noninvasive clinical staging procedures, including sonography and computerized tomography, revealed complete remission in 24 per cent and partial remission in 39 per cent. Of 30 patients who underwent pathological staging 33 per cent achieved stage P0 and 17 per cent stage Tis disease or P less than T. Despite extensive re-evaluation by transurethral resection of the bladder and other noninvasive staging procedures, a clinical staging error (T versus P) of 38 per cent was observed. Of the other 9 patients 4 with mixed nontransitional cell histological findings at presentation never achieved complete remission, although 3 had resolution of all transitional cell elements and 5 (10 per cent) were inevaluable. The toxicity of the regimen was generally acceptable but 6 per cent of the patients required hospitalization for neutropenic fever. While this active regimen can clinically (T) and pathologically (P) induce downstaging in a significant number of patients with primary bladder tumors, this pilot study has raised serious questions concerning the design of future nonrandomized and randomized neoadjuvant studies.
在一项I期和II期的初步研究中,50例膀胱癌患者接受了1至5个周期的新辅助甲氨蝶呤、长春碱、阿霉素和顺铂治疗,41例纯移行细胞期T2 - 4病变患者中有63%出现反应。虽然70%的患者经膀胱经尿道切除术、60%的患者经细胞学检查出现显著降期,但包括超声和计算机断层扫描在内的所有非侵入性临床分期程序的最终T反应率显示,24%的患者完全缓解,39%的患者部分缓解。在30例接受病理分期的患者中,33%达到P0期,17%达到Tis期或P小于T期。尽管通过膀胱经尿道切除术和其他非侵入性分期程序进行了广泛的重新评估,但仍观察到38%的临床分期错误(T与P)。在其他9例患者中,4例在初诊时具有混合性非移行细胞组织学表现,从未实现完全缓解,尽管其中3例所有移行细胞成分消失,5例(10%)无法评估。该方案的毒性总体上可以接受,但6%的患者因中性粒细胞减少性发热需要住院治疗。虽然这种积极的方案可以在临床上(T)和病理上(P)使大量原发性膀胱肿瘤患者出现降期,但这项初步研究对未来非随机和随机新辅助研究的设计提出了严重质疑。