Centre of Methods and Policy Application in the Social Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand.
PLoS One. 2021 Jan 13;16(1):e0243920. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0243920. eCollection 2021.
Very little high quality evidence exists on the causal relationship between income poverty and childhood health. We provide a comprehensive overview of the association between household income poverty and hospitalisations for children.
We used New Zealand's Integrated Data Infrastructure (IDI) to link income poverty data from the Survey of Family, Income and Employment (SoFIE; n = 21,759 households) and the 2013 New Zealand Census (n = 523,302 households) to publicly funded hospital records of children aged 0-17 (SoFIE: n = 39,459; Census, n = 986,901). Poverty was defined as equivalised household income below 60% of the median income, calculated both before and after housing costs, and using both self-reported and tax-recorded income.
Correlations for the association between income poverty and hospitalisation were small (ranging from 0.02 to 0.05) and risk ratios were less than 1.35 for all but the rarest outcome-oral health hospitalisation. Weak or absent associations were apparent across age groups, waves of data collection, cumulative effects, and for estimates generated from fixed effects models and random effect models adjusted for age and ethnicity. Alternative measures of deprivation (area-level deprivation and material deprivation) showed stronger associations with hospitalisations (risk ratios ranged from 1.27-2.55) than income-based poverty measures.
Income poverty is at best weakly associated with hospitalisation in childhood. Measures of deprivation may have a stronger association. Income measures alone may not be sufficient to capture the diversity of household economic circumstances when assessing the poverty-health relationship.
关于收入贫困与儿童健康之间因果关系的高质量证据非常有限。我们全面概述了家庭收入贫困与儿童住院治疗之间的关联。
我们使用新西兰综合数据基础设施 (IDI) 将来自家庭、收入和就业调查 (SoFIE;n = 21,759 户) 的收入贫困数据与 2013 年新西兰人口普查 (n = 523,302 户) 相链接,以获取儿童 (SoFIE:n = 39,459;人口普查,n = 986,901) 的公共资助住院记录。贫困被定义为家庭收入低于中位数的 60%,在计算时既考虑了住房成本之前和之后的收入,又考虑了自我报告的和纳税记录的收入。
收入贫困与住院治疗之间的相关性很小(范围从 0.02 到 0.05),除了最罕见的口腔健康住院治疗外,所有结果的风险比都小于 1.35。在所有年龄段、数据收集波次、累积效应中,以及从固定效应模型和随机效应模型调整年龄和族裔因素生成的估计值中,都出现了较弱或不存在的关联。贫困的替代衡量指标(地区贫困和物质贫困)与住院治疗的相关性更强(风险比范围为 1.27-2.55),而不是基于收入的贫困衡量指标。
收入贫困与儿童住院治疗的关联最多也只是微弱相关。贫困衡量指标可能具有更强的关联。在评估贫困与健康之间的关系时,仅收入衡量指标可能不足以捕捉家庭经济状况的多样性。