Wright Alison J, Norris Emma, Finnerty Ailbhe N, Marques Marta M, Johnston Marie, Kelly Michael P, Hastings Janna, West Robert, Michie Susan
Centre for Behaviour Change, University College London, London, UK.
ADAPT SFI Research Centre, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Wellcome Open Res. 2020 Dec 18;5:126. doi: 10.12688/wellcomeopenres.15908.3. eCollection 2020.
Behaviour and behaviour change are integral to many aspects of wellbeing and sustainability. However, reporting behaviour change interventions accurately and synthesising evidence about effective interventions is hindered by lacking a shared, scientific terminology to describe intervention characteristics. Ontologies are standardised frameworks that provide controlled vocabularies to help unify and connect scientific fields. To date, there is no published guidance on the specific methods required to develop ontologies relevant to behaviour change. We report the creation and refinement of a method for developing ontologies that make up the Behaviour Change Intervention Ontology (BCIO). (1) To describe the development method of the BCIO and explain its rationale; (2) To provide guidance on implementing the activities within the development method. The method for developing ontologies relevant to behaviour change interventions was constructed by considering principles of good practice in ontology development and identifying key activities required to follow those principles. The method's details were refined through application to developing two ontologies. The resulting ontology development method involved: (1) defining the ontology's scope; (2) identifying key entities; (3) refining the ontology through an iterative process of literature annotation, discussion and revision; (4) expert stakeholder review; (5) testing inter-rater reliability; (6) specifying relationships between entities, and; (7) disseminating and maintaining the ontology. Guidance is provided for conducting relevant activities for each step. We have developed a detailed method for creating ontologies relevant to behaviour change interventions, together with practical guidance for each step, reflecting principles of good practice in ontology development. The most novel aspects of the method are the use of formal mechanisms for literature annotation and expert stakeholder review to develop and improve the ontology content. We suggest the mnemonic SELAR3, representing the method's first six steps as Scope, Entities, Literature Annotation, Review, Reliability, Relationships.
行为及行为改变是幸福和可持续性诸多方面的核心要素。然而,由于缺乏用于描述干预特征的共享科学术语,准确报告行为改变干预措施以及综合有效干预措施的证据受到了阻碍。本体是提供受控词汇表以帮助统一和连接科学领域的标准化框架。迄今为止,尚无关于开发与行为改变相关本体所需具体方法的公开指南。我们报告了一种用于开发构成行为改变干预本体(BCIO)的本体的创建和完善方法。(1)描述BCIO的开发方法并解释其基本原理;(2)为实施开发方法中的活动提供指导。通过考虑本体开发中的良好实践原则并确定遵循这些原则所需的关键活动,构建了与行为改变干预相关的本体开发方法。通过将该方法应用于开发两个本体来完善其细节。由此产生的本体开发方法包括:(1)定义本体的范围;(2)识别关键实体;(3)通过文献注释、讨论和修订的迭代过程完善本体;(4)专家利益相关者审查;(5)测试评分者间信度;(6)指定实体之间的关系,以及(7)传播和维护本体。针对每个步骤的相关活动提供了指导。我们已经开发了一种用于创建与行为改变干预相关本体的详细方法,以及每个步骤的实用指南,体现了本体开发中的良好实践原则。该方法最新颖的方面是使用正式机制进行文献注释和专家利益相关者审查,以开发和改进本体内容。我们建议使用助记符SELAR3,将该方法的前六个步骤表示为范围(Scope)、实体(Entities)、文献注释(Literature Annotation)、审查(Review)、信度(Reliability)、关系(Relationships)。