Department of Urology, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, USA.
Simulation Innovation Laboratory, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, USA.
J Endourol. 2021 Mar;35(3):383-389. doi: 10.1089/end.2020.0405. Epub 2021 Feb 23.
The use of volume-rendered images is gaining popularity in the surgical planning for complex procedures. IRIS™ is an interactive software that delivers three-dimensional (3D) virtual anatomical models. We aimed to evaluate the preoperative clinical utility of IRIS for patients with ≤T2 localized renal tumors who underwent either partial nephrectomy (PN) or radical nephrectomy (RN). Six urologists (four faculty and two trainees) reviewed CT scans of 40 cases over 2 study phases, using conventional two-dimensional (2D) CT alone (Phase-I), followed by the CT + IRIS 3D model (Phase-II). After each review, surgeons reported their decision on performing a PN or an RN and rated (Likert scale) their confidence in completing the procedure as well as how the imaging modality influenced specific procedural decisions. Modifications to the choice of procedure and confidence in decisions between both phases were compared for the same surgeon. Concordance between surgeons was also evaluated. A total of 462 reviews were included in the analysis (231 in each phase). In 64% (95% CI: 58-70%) of reviews, surgeons reported that IRIS achieved a better spatial orientation, understanding of the anatomy, and offered additional information compared with 2D CT alone. IRIS impacted the planned procedure in 20% of the reviews (3.5% changed decision from PN to RN and 16.5% changed from RN to PN). In the remaining 80% of reviews, surgeons' confidence increased from 78% (95% CI: 72-84%) with 2D CT, to 87% (95% CI: 82-92%) with IRIS ( = 0.02); this confidence change was more pronounced in cases with a high RENAL score ( = 0.009). In 99% of the reviews, surgeons rated that the IRIS accurately represented the anatomical details of all kidney components. Application of IRIS 3D models could influence the surgical decision-making process and improve surgeons' confidence, especially for robot-assisted management of complex renal tumors.
容积再现图像的使用在复杂手术的术前规划中越来越受欢迎。IRIS™ 是一种交互式软件,可提供三维(3D)虚拟解剖模型。我们旨在评估 IRIS 在接受部分肾切除术(PN)或根治性肾切除术(RN)的≤T2 局限性肾肿瘤患者中的术前临床应用价值。六名泌尿科医生(四名教员和两名学员)在两个研究阶段使用传统的二维(2D)CT 单独(第 I 阶段)和 CT + IRIS 3D 模型(第 II 阶段)对 40 例病例的 CT 扫描进行了回顾。每次回顾后,外科医生报告他们进行 PN 或 RN 的决定,并对完成手术的信心程度(Likert 量表)以及成像方式如何影响特定手术决策进行评分。比较了同一外科医生在两个阶段之间对手术方式的选择和决策信心的改变。还评估了外科医生之间的一致性。共有 462 次回顾纳入分析(各阶段 231 次)。在 64%(95%CI:58-70%)的回顾中,外科医生报告称,与单独使用 2D CT 相比,IRIS 能够更好地实现空间定位、理解解剖结构并提供额外信息。IRIS 影响了 20%的回顾中的计划手术(3.5%的病例从 PN 改为 RN,16.5%的病例从 RN 改为 PN)。在其余 80%的回顾中,外科医生的信心从使用 2D CT 时的 78%(95%CI:72-84%)增加到使用 IRIS 时的 87%(95%CI:82-92%)( = 0.02);对于 RENAL 评分较高的病例,这种信心变化更为明显( = 0.009)。在 99%的回顾中,外科医生评价 IRIS 准确地代表了所有肾脏成分的解剖细节。IRIS 3D 模型的应用可以影响手术决策过程并提高外科医生的信心,特别是在机器人辅助处理复杂肾肿瘤方面。