Gschwend N, Ivosević-Radovanović D, Patte D
Klinik W. Schulthess, Zürich, Switzerland.
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (1978). 1988;107(1):7-15. doi: 10.1007/BF00463518.
Rotator cuff tears (RCT) are frequent and increase with age. Why do only a relatively small percentage cause a permanent severe handicap justifying surgery? Is there a relationship between size and site of the tear and the clinical symptoms? How do they influence the postoperative result? These questions were answered in a prospective study of 76 operated patients. We adopted D. Patte's classification of the RCT into four groups according to the site and size of the lesion. Our figures were compared with those obtained by Patte in an analogous study of 256 cases. Of the tears in our series, 56.5% belonged to groups I and II, which means that only the supraspinatous and occasionally also the subscapular muscles were involved. In 100% of the cases in group I we found only pain, whereas a pure symptomatology with pain alone was presented in only 51% of group II, in 48% of group III, and in 0% of group IV. Groups III (35.5%) and IV (8%) represent more extensive tears, involving not only the anterior part of the rotator cuff, e.g., the supraspinatous tendon, but also to a more or less severe extent, the infraspinatous and sometimes even the teres minor. In group IV the extensive tear is combined with osteoarthritic changes. In both groups a mixed symptomatology (pain and pseudoparalysis) is the rule. The result of operative treatment is satisfactory in all groups as far as pain relief is concerned. The improvement of active ROM is not as evident and seems, as expected, to be related to the severity of the lesion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
肩袖撕裂(RCT)很常见,且随年龄增长而增加。为什么只有相对较小比例的撕裂会导致需要手术治疗的永久性严重功能障碍?撕裂的大小和部位与临床症状之间有关系吗?它们如何影响术后结果?在一项对76例接受手术患者的前瞻性研究中回答了这些问题。我们采用了D. 帕特(D. Patte)根据损伤部位和大小将RCT分为四组的分类方法。我们的数据与帕特在一项对256例病例的类似研究中获得的数据进行了比较。在我们的系列病例中,56.5%的撕裂属于I组和II组,这意味着仅冈上肌,偶尔还有肩胛下肌受累。在I组的所有病例中,我们仅发现疼痛,而仅表现为单纯疼痛症状的情况在II组中仅占51%,在III组中占48%,在IV组中占0%。III组(35.5%)和IV组(8%)代表更广泛的撕裂,不仅累及肩袖的前部,如冈上肌腱,还或多或少严重累及冈下肌,有时甚至累及小圆肌。在IV组中,广泛的撕裂合并有关节炎改变。在这两组中,混合症状(疼痛和假性麻痹)是常见的。就疼痛缓解而言,所有组的手术治疗结果都令人满意。主动活动度(ROM)的改善不那么明显,而且正如预期的那样,似乎与损伤的严重程度有关。(摘要截断于250字)