Dunn John C, Elster Eric A, Blair James A, Remick Kyle N, Potter Benjamin K, Nesti Leon J
Clinical and Experimental Orthopaedics, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD 79922, USA.
William Beaumont Army Medical Center, Fort Bliss, TX 79922, USA.
Mil Med. 2022 Jan 4;187(1-2):e17-e21. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usaa379.
Trauma systems within the United States have adapted the "golden hour" principle to guide prehospital planning with the goal to deliver the injured to the trauma facility in under 60 minutes. In an effort to reduce preventable prehospital death, in 2009, Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates mandated that prehospital transport of injured combat casualties must be less than 60 minutes. The U.S. Military has implemented a 60-minute timeline for the transport of battlefield causalities to medical teams to include Forward Surgical Teams and Forward Resuscitative Surgical Teams. The inclusion of orthopedic surgeons on Forward Surgical Teams has been extrapolated from the concept of damage control orthopedics (DCO). However, it is not clear if orthopedic surgeons have yielded a demonstrable benefit in morbidity or mortality reduction. The purpose of this article is to investigate the function of orthopedic surgeons during the military "golden hour."
The English literature was reviewed for evidence supporting the use of orthopedic surgeons within the golden hour. Literature was reviewed in light of the 2009 golden hour mandate by Secretary Gates as well as those papers which highlighted the utility of DCO within the golden hour.
Evidence for orthopedic surgery within the "golden hour" or in the current conflicts when the United States enjoys air superiority was not identified.
Within the military context, DCO, specifically pertaining to fracture fixation, should not be considered an element of golden hour planning and thus orthopedic surgeons are best utilized at more centralized Role 3 facility locations. The focus within the first hour after injury on the battlefield should be maintained on rapid and effective prehospital care combined with timely evacuation, as these are the most critical factors to reducing mortality.
美国的创伤系统采用了“黄金一小时”原则来指导院前规划,目标是在60分钟内将伤者送达创伤治疗机构。为减少可预防的院前死亡,2009年,国防部长罗伯特·M·盖茨下令,受伤战斗伤员的院前转运时间必须少于60分钟。美国军方为将战场伤员转运至医疗团队(包括前方外科团队和前方复苏外科团队)设定了60分钟的时间限制。前方外科团队纳入骨科医生是从损伤控制骨科(DCO)的概念引申而来。然而,目前尚不清楚骨科医生在降低发病率或死亡率方面是否产生了显著益处。本文旨在研究骨科医生在军事“黄金一小时”期间的作用。
回顾英文文献,寻找支持在黄金一小时内使用骨科医生的证据。根据盖茨部长2009年的黄金一小时指令以及那些强调DCO在黄金一小时内效用的论文对文献进行了回顾。
未找到在“黄金一小时”内或在美国享有空中优势的当前冲突中进行骨科手术的证据。
在军事背景下,DCO,特别是与骨折固定相关的内容,不应被视为黄金一小时规划的要素,因此骨科医生最好在更集中的三级医疗机构中发挥作用。战场上受伤后第一小时的重点应保持在快速有效的院前护理以及及时后送,因为这些是降低死亡率的最关键因素。