Yadav Urvashi, Singh Rakesh Bahadur, Chaudhari Shweta, Srivastava Swati
Department of Anaesthesiology, Uttar Pradesh University of Medical Sciences, Etawah, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Anesth Essays Res. 2020 Apr-Jun;14(2):213-218. doi: 10.4103/aer.AER_52_20. Epub 2020 Oct 12.
The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of airway sonographic parameters as the predictors of difficult laryngoscopy and to evaluate the validity of combined sonographic and clinical tests.
This prospective and observational study analyzed a sample of 200 patients who were categorized as having easy (Grades 1 and 2) or difficult (Grades 3 and 4) laryngoscopy based on the laryngoscopic criteria of Cormack-Lahane (CL). Sonographic parameters, including the anterior neck soft-tissue thickness at the level of vocal cord (ANS-VC), ANS tissue thickness at the level of hyoid, and ratio of depth of pre-epiglottic space to distance from epiglottis to midpoint of the distance between vocal cords and clinical parameters, including modified Mallampati class, thyromental distance, and hyomental distance ratio (HMDR), were analyzed. Univariate and multivariate regression analysis was used for the statistical analysis.
Twenty patients (10%) were categorized as having difficult laryngoscopy. Statistically significant differences between patients with difficult and easy laryngoscopy were noted for 5 of 6 parameters. The diagnostic validity profiles showed variable sensitivity (26.5%-87.5%) and good specificity (58.9%-94.2%) and negative predictive value (88.8%-97.03%). ANS-VC has the highest sensitivity (87.50%) and area under curve value (0.887), whereas HMDR showed highest specificity (94.2%) and highest accuracy (89.60%) which means it has low false-positive prediction rate. The combination of tests improved the diagnostic validity profile (highest area under the curve, 0.897).
Sonographic predictors can help in identifying difficult laryngoscopy. Combined clinical and ultrasonographic parameters showed better validity profiles in comparison to the individual tests.
本研究旨在评估气道超声参数作为困难喉镜检查预测指标的有效性,并评估超声检查与临床检查相结合的有效性。
本前瞻性观察性研究分析了200例患者的样本,根据Cormack-Lahane(CL)喉镜检查标准将其分为喉镜检查容易(1级和2级)或困难(3级和4级)的患者。分析了超声参数,包括声带水平的颈前软组织厚度(ANS-VC)、舌骨水平的ANS组织厚度、会厌前间隙深度与会厌至声带间距离中点距离的比值,以及临床参数,包括改良Mallampati分级、甲颏距离和舌颏距离比值(HMDR)。采用单因素和多因素回归分析进行统计分析。
20例患者(10%)被归类为喉镜检查困难。在6项参数中的5项上,困难喉镜检查患者与容易喉镜检查患者之间存在统计学显著差异。诊断有效性分析显示,敏感性各异(26.5%-87.5%),特异性良好(58.9%-94.2%),阴性预测值较高(88.8%-97.03%)。ANS-VC具有最高的敏感性(87.50%)和曲线下面积值(0.887),而HMDR显示出最高的特异性(94.2%)和最高的准确性(89.60%),这意味着其假阳性预测率较低。联合检查改善了诊断有效性分析结果(最高曲线下面积为0.897)。
超声预测指标有助于识别困难喉镜检查。与单独检查相比,临床和超声参数相结合显示出更好的有效性分析结果。