Meacham Meredith C, Ramo Danielle E, Prochaska Judith J, Maier Larissa J, Delucchi Kevin L, Kaur Manpreet, Satre Derek D
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Weill Institute for Neurosciences, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States of America.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Weill Institute for Neurosciences, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States of America; Hopelab, San Francisco, CA, United States of America.
J Subst Abuse Treat. 2021 Mar;122:108211. doi: 10.1016/j.jsat.2020.108211. Epub 2020 Nov 23.
Co-occurrence of tobacco use and heavy episodic drinking (HED; 5+ drinks for men and 4+ drinks for women per occasion) is common among young adults; both warrant attention and intervention. In a two-group randomized pilot trial, we investigated whether a Facebook-based smoking cessation intervention addressing both alcohol and tobacco use would increase smoking abstinence and reduce HED compared to a similar intervention addressing only tobacco.
Participants were 179 young adults (age 18-25; 49.7% male; 80.4% non-Hispanic white) recruited from Facebook and Instagram who reported smoking 4+ days/week and past-month HED. The Smoking Tobacco and Drinking (STAND) intervention (N = 84) and the Tobacco Status Project (TSP), a tobacco-only intervention (N = 95), both included daily Facebook posts for 90 days and weekly live counseling sessions in private "secret" groups. We verified self-reported 7-day smoking abstinence via remote salivary cotinine tests at 3, 6, and 12 months (with retention at 83%, 66%, and 84%, respectively). Participants self-reported alcohol use.
At baseline, the participants averaged 10.4 cigarettes per day (SD = 6.9) and 8.9 HED occasions in the past month (SD = 8.1), with 27.4% in a preparation stage of change for quitting smoking cigarettes. Participants reported significant improvements in cigarette smoking and alcohol use outcomes over time, with no significant differences by condition. At 12 months, intent-to-treat smoking abstinence rates were 3.5% in STAND vs. 0% in TSP (biochemically verified) and 29.4% in STAND vs. 25.5% in TSP (self-reported). Compared to TSP, participants rated the STAND intervention more favorably for supporting health and providing useful information.
Adding an alcohol treatment component to a tobacco cessation social media intervention was acceptable and engaging but did not result in significant differences by treatment condition in smoking or alcohol use outcomes. Participants in both conditions reported smoking and drinking less over time, suggesting covariation in behavioral changes.
在年轻人中,吸烟与大量饮酒(男性每次饮用5杯及以上,女性每次饮用4杯及以上)同时存在的情况很常见;这两者都需要关注和干预。在一项两组随机试点试验中,我们调查了与仅针对烟草的类似干预相比,基于Facebook的同时针对酒精和烟草使用的戒烟干预是否会增加戒烟率并减少大量饮酒。
参与者是从Facebook和Instagram招募的179名年轻人(年龄18 - 25岁;49.7%为男性;80.4%为非西班牙裔白人),他们报告每周吸烟4天以上且在过去一个月有大量饮酒情况。吸烟与饮酒(STAND)干预组(N = 84)和仅针对烟草的烟草状况项目(TSP)干预组(N = 95),都包括为期90天的每日Facebook帖子以及在私人“秘密”群组中进行的每周一次现场咨询会议。我们在3个月、6个月和12个月时通过远程唾液可替宁测试核实自我报告的7天戒烟情况(保留率分别为83%、66%和84%)。参与者自我报告酒精使用情况。
在基线时,参与者平均每天吸烟10.4支(标准差 = 6.9),在过去一个月中有8.9次大量饮酒情况(标准差 = 8.1),其中27.4%处于戒烟的准备阶段。随着时间推移,参与者报告在吸烟和酒精使用结果方面有显著改善,各条件之间无显著差异。在12个月时,意向性分析的戒烟率在STAND组中为3.5%(经生化验证),在TSP组中为0%;自我报告的戒烟率在STAND组中为29.4%,在TSP组中为25.5%。与TSP相比,参与者对STAND干预在支持健康和提供有用信息方面的评价更高。
在戒烟社交媒体干预中增加酒精治疗部分是可以接受且有吸引力的,但在吸烟或酒精使用结果方面,治疗条件之间没有显著差异。两种条件下的参与者都报告随着时间推移吸烟和饮酒减少,表明行为变化存在共变关系。