Department of Family Medicine, 5140Charles R Drew University of Medicine and Science (CDU), Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Department of Public Health, 5140Charles R Drew University of Medicine and Science, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2021 Jun;38(6):601-609. doi: 10.1177/1049909121991522. Epub 2021 Feb 4.
Numerous studies have documented multilevel racial inequalities in health care utilization, medical treatment, and quality of care in minority populations in the United States. Palliative care for people with serious illness and hospice services for people approaching the end of life are no exception. It is also well established that Hispanics and non-Hispanic Blacks are more likely than non-Hispanic Whites to have less knowledge about advance care planning and directives, hospice, and palliative care. Both qualitative and quantitative research has identified lack of awareness of palliative and hospice services as one of the major factors contributing to the underuse of these services by minority populations. However, an insufficient number of racial/ethnic comparative studies have been conducted to examine associations among various independent factors in relation to awareness of end-of-life, palliative care and advance care planning and directives.
The main objective of this analysis was to examine correlates of awareness of palliative, hospice care and advance directives in a racially and ethnically diverse large sample of California adults.
This cross-sectional study includes 2,328 adults: Hispanics (31%); non-Hispanic Blacks (30%); and non-Hispanic Whites (39%) from the Survey of California Adults on Serious Illness and End-of-Life 2019. Using multivariate analysis, we adjusted for demographic and socio-economic variables while estimating the potential independent impact of health status, lack of primary care providers, and recent experiences of participants with a family member with serious illnesses.
Hispanic and non-Hispanic Black participants are far less likely to report that they have heard about palliative and hospice care and advance directives than their non-Hispanic White counterparts. In this study, 75%, 74%, and 49% of Hispanics, non-Hispanic Blacks, and non-Hispanic White participants, respectively, claimed that they have never heard about palliative care. Multivariate analysis of data show gender, age, education, and income all significantly were associated with awareness. Furthermore, being engaged with decision making for a loved one with serious illnesses and having a primary care provider were associated with awareness of palliative care and advance directives.
Our findings reveal that lack of awareness of hospice and palliative care and advance directives among California adults is largely influenced by race and ethnicity. In addition, demographic and socio-economic variables, health status, access to primary care providers, and having informal care giving experience were all independently associated with awareness of advance directives and palliative and hospice care. These effects are complex, which may be attributed to various historical, social, and cultural mechanisms at the individual, community, and organizational levels. A large number of factors should be addressed in order to increase knowledge and awareness of end-of-life and palliative care as well as completion of advance directives and planning. The results of this study may guide the design of multi-level community and theoretically-based awareness and training models that enhance awareness of palliative care, hospice care, and advance directives among minority populations.
许多研究都记录了在美国少数民族群体中,医疗保健利用、医疗治疗和护理质量方面存在多层次的种族不平等现象。在患有严重疾病的人群中提供姑息治疗和为生命末期的人群提供临终关怀服务也不例外。此外,人们还普遍认识到,西班牙裔和非西班牙裔黑人比非西班牙裔白人更有可能不太了解预先护理计划和指示、临终关怀和姑息治疗。定性和定量研究都已经确定,对姑息治疗和临终关怀服务的认识不足是导致少数群体对这些服务利用不足的主要因素之一。然而,由于各种独立因素与临终、姑息治疗和预先护理计划和指示意识相关,进行足够数量的种族/民族比较研究的数量还不够。
本分析的主要目的是检查加利福尼亚州成年人中种族和民族多样化的大样本中对姑息治疗、临终关怀和预先护理计划和指示意识的相关因素。
这项横断面研究包括 2328 名成年人:西班牙裔(31%);非西班牙裔黑人(30%);和非西班牙裔白人(39%),他们来自 2019 年加利福尼亚成年人严重疾病和临终调查。使用多变量分析,我们在估计健康状况、缺乏初级保健提供者以及参与者最近与患有严重疾病的家庭成员一起的经历对潜在独立影响的同时,调整了人口统计学和社会经济变量。
西班牙裔和非西班牙裔黑人参与者报告听说过姑息治疗、临终关怀和预先护理计划和指示的可能性远远低于非西班牙裔白人参与者。在这项研究中,分别有 75%、74%和 49%的西班牙裔、非西班牙裔黑人和非西班牙裔白人参与者声称他们从未听说过姑息治疗。对数据的多变量分析表明,性别、年龄、教育程度和收入都与意识显著相关。此外,参与对患有严重疾病的亲人的决策以及有初级保健提供者与对姑息治疗和预先护理计划和指示的意识有关。
我们的研究结果表明,加利福尼亚成年人对临终关怀和姑息治疗以及预先护理计划和指示的认识在很大程度上受到种族和民族的影响。此外,人口统计学和社会经济变量、健康状况、获得初级保健提供者的机会以及有非正式护理经验都与对预先护理计划和指示以及姑息治疗和临终关怀的意识独立相关。这些影响是复杂的,这可能归因于个体、社区和组织层面的各种历史、社会和文化机制。为了提高对临终关怀和姑息治疗以及预先护理计划和指示的认识,需要解决许多因素。本研究结果可能指导设计多层次的社区和基于理论的意识和培训模型,以提高少数民族群体对姑息治疗、临终关怀和预先护理计划和指示的认识。