Department of Hospital Institutional Research, University of Miyazaki Hospital, 5200 Kibara Kiyotake-cho, Miyazaki, 8891692, Japan.
Graduate School of Medicine and Veterinary Medicine, University of Miyazaki, 5200 Kibara Kiyotake-cho, Miyazaki, 8891692, Japan.
J Med Syst. 2021 Feb 5;45(3):33. doi: 10.1007/s10916-021-01714-x.
This study aimed to improve generalizability of our previous study that analyzed clinical pathway (CP) completion. Although our previous study demonstrated that CP completion can reduce the length of hospital stay, it is possible for few medical organizations to extract the implementation of treatment registered on CP from typical electronic medical records. Therefore, we have defined a prospective event for event substitution, called meal completion (MC), in which patients can take their meal daily. Data were collected from April 2013 to March 2018 from the electronic medical records of the University of Miyazaki Hospital. We used propensity score matching to extract records from 8033 patients. Patients were further divided into the MC and non-MC groups; 2577 patients in each group were available for data analysis. The numbers of patients with CP completion were 646 (28.1%) in the MC group and 411 (18.2%) in the non-MC group. The P value of the chi-square test was <0.001. According to this result, there was the causation from MC to increase in CP completion. Additionally, it was possible to consider the inclusion relationship in all treatments (universal set), treatments registered on CP (subset of all treatments), and meals (subset of treatments registered on CP). In conclusion, MC can substitute for CP completion because the demonstration is appropriate for the Prentice criterion, which is often used for the evaluation of a surrogate endpoint.
本研究旨在提高我们之前分析临床路径(CP)完成情况的研究的通用性。尽管我们之前的研究表明 CP 完成可以缩短住院时间,但很少有医疗机构能够从典型的电子病历中提取 CP 上登记的治疗实施情况。因此,我们定义了一个前瞻性事件作为事件替代,称为膳食完成(MC),患者可以每天进食。数据来自 2013 年 4 月至 2018 年 3 月期间的宫崎大学医院电子病历。我们使用倾向评分匹配从 8033 名患者中提取记录。将患者进一步分为 MC 和非 MC 组;每组 2577 名患者可用于数据分析。MC 组 CP 完成的患者数为 646 例(28.1%),非 MC 组为 411 例(18.2%)。卡方检验的 P 值<0.001。根据这一结果,可以认为 MC 导致 CP 完成增加。此外,还可以考虑所有治疗方法(全集)、CP 上登记的治疗方法(所有治疗方法的子集)和膳食(CP 上登记的治疗方法的子集)之间的包含关系。总之,MC 可以替代 CP 完成,因为这一证明符合替代终点评估中常用的 Prentice 标准。