University of Teacher Education of the State of Vaud, Special Needs Education Unit, Av. de Cour 33, 1014, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Res Dev Disabil. 2021 Apr;111:103883. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2021.103883. Epub 2021 Feb 3.
To date, only a few studies with randomized controlled trials have been published on the effectiveness of phonics-based reading interventions to teach decoding and spelling skills to students with intellectual disability.
This study evaluated the effects of a phonics-based reading intervention program on the progress of French-speaking elementary students with intellectual disability.
A total of 48 non decoding elementary students with intellectual disability were randomly assigned to either a treatment group or a control group. Most of the participants (75 %) had nonverbal IQs below 55. The reading intervention program was implemented for seven months by the students' teachers and mainly in a small-group format (two to four students).
Students from the treatment group made significantly more progress in word and nonword reading measured by a researcher-designed test with a medium effect size. An almost significant difference was also found on spelling (p = .058) and on word and nonword reading measured with a standardized test (p = .060) with medium effect sizes.
These findings suggest that students with ID benefit from phonics-based programs integrating research-based approaches and techniques.
迄今为止,仅有少数几项基于语音的阅读干预研究发表了随机对照试验结果,以评估其对有智力障碍的学生进行解码和拼写技能教学的效果。
本研究评估了基于语音的阅读干预方案对法语为母语的有智力障碍的小学生的进步的影响。
共有 48 名非解码的有智力障碍的小学生被随机分配到治疗组或对照组。大多数参与者(75%)的非言语智商低于 55。阅读干预方案由学生的教师实施,持续七个月,主要以小组形式(两到四名学生)进行。
通过研究者设计的测试评估,治疗组的学生在单词和非单词阅读方面取得了显著进步,具有中等效应量。在拼写(p=.058)和使用标准化测试评估的单词和非单词阅读(p=.060)方面也发现了几乎显著的差异,具有中等效应量。
这些发现表明,有智力障碍的学生从整合了基于研究的方法和技术的基于语音的方案中受益。