Zheng Elise Li
Department of History and Sociology of Science and Technology, Georgia Institute of Technology, 221 Bobby Dodd Way, Atlanta, GA 30309 USA.
AI Soc. 2021 Feb 7:1-12. doi: 10.1007/s00146-021-01146-8.
Fitness apps on mobile devices are gaining popularity, as more people are engaging in self-tracking activities to record their status of fitness and exercise routines. These technologies also evolved from simply recording steps and offering exercise suggestions to an integrated lifestyle guide for physical wellbeing, thus exemplify a new era of "quantified self" in the context of health as individual responsibility. There is a considerable amount of literature in science, technology and society (STS) studies looking at this phenomenon from different perspectives, linking it with the sociology of self-surveillance and neoliberal regimes of health. However, the human-technology interface, through which the micro- (behavioral) and macro- (social) aspects converge, still calls for extensive examination. This paper approaches this topic from the postphenomenological perspective, in combination with empirical studies of design analysis and interviews of fitness apps, to reveal the human-technology link between the design elements and people's perception through the direct experiences and interpretations of technology. It argues that the intentionality of self-tracking fitness app designs mediates the human-technology relations by "guiding" people into a quantified knowledge regime. It shapes the perceptions of fitness and health with representations of meanings about a "good life" of individual success and management. This paper also gives a critique of current individual, performance-oriented fitness app designs and offers the possibility of seeking alternatives through the multistable nature of human-technology relations-how altering interpretation and meaning of the design with a cultural or social context could change the form of technological embodiment.
移动设备上的健身应用越来越受欢迎,因为越来越多的人参与自我追踪活动,以记录他们的健康状况和日常锻炼情况。这些技术也从简单地记录步数和提供锻炼建议,发展成为一种综合的身体健康生活方式指南,从而在个人对健康负责的背景下,例证了“量化自我”的新时代。科学、技术与社会(STS)研究领域有大量文献从不同角度审视这一现象,并将其与自我监控社会学和新自由主义健康体制联系起来。然而,微观(行为)和宏观(社会)层面通过其交汇的人机界面,仍需要进行广泛研究。本文从后现象学视角探讨这一主题,结合设计分析的实证研究和对健身应用的访谈,通过技术的直接体验和解读,揭示设计元素与人们认知之间的人机联系。本文认为,自我追踪健身应用设计的意向性通过将人们“引导”到量化知识体系中,调节人机关系。它通过关于个人成功和管理的“美好生活”意义的表征,塑造了人们对健康和健身的认知。本文还对当前以个人表现为导向的健身应用设计进行了批判,并通过人机关系的多稳态性质,提供了寻求替代方案的可能性——即如何通过文化或社会背景改变设计的解读和意义,从而改变技术体现的形式。