Department of Health and Nutritional Sciences, IT Sligo, Sligo, Ireland.
Academic Department of Palliative Medicine, Our Lady's Hospice & Care Services, Dublin, Ireland.
JCO Oncol Pract. 2021 Jul;17(7):e982-e991. doi: 10.1200/OP.20.00685. Epub 2021 Feb 17.
Credible evidence-based diet and nutrition advice is essential for patients with cancer. This study aimed to explore what advice patients with cancer obtained before a formal dietetic visit.
A multicenter, observational study was conducted in seven hospital-based oncology services. Consecutive patients were recruited at first dietetic assessment. In addition to routine dietetic assessment, participants completed a four-item questionnaire describing diet and nutrition advice obtained since diagnosis.
Seventy-seven patients participated. More than 80% had multiple nutrition-impact symptoms. In total, 53 (69%) obtained advice from professional and nonprofessional sources before dietetic visit. Family and friends were the most common sources of advice. More than one third got advice from (nondietetic) healthcare professionals. Most advice related to "foods to include" (61%) and "foods to avoid" (54%) in the diet. Many of the "foods to avoid" were important sources of micro- and macronutrients. Advice about dietary supplements (31%) and specific diets (28%) was common, rarely evidence-based, and frequently contradictory. Participants found it difficult to discern what advice was trustworthy and reliable. Despite this, most followed the advice.
The majority of patients received diet and nutrition advice before first dietetic visit. Most of this came from nonprofessional sources. Any advice from nondietetic healthcare professionals was inconsistent or vague. This was mainly related to the avoidance and/or inclusion of particular foods and was often contradictory. Nevertheless, patients usually followed such advice fully. To help manage their frequent nutrition-impact symptoms and resolve the contradictory advice they had received, many expressed the need for earlier professional dietetic consultation.
为癌症患者提供可信的循证饮食和营养建议至关重要。本研究旨在探讨癌症患者在正式接受营养咨询之前获得了哪些建议。
在七家医院的肿瘤中心进行了一项多中心、观察性研究。在首次营养评估时连续招募患者。除了常规的营养评估外,参与者还填写了一份四项的问卷,描述自诊断以来获得的饮食和营养建议。
共有 77 名患者参与了研究。超过 80%的患者有多种营养相关症状。总的来说,53 名(69%)患者在就诊前从专业和非专业来源获得了建议。家人和朋友是最常见的建议来源。超过三分之一的患者从(非营养)医疗保健专业人员那里获得了建议。大多数建议涉及饮食中“应包含的食物”(61%)和“应避免的食物”(54%)。许多“应避免的食物”是微量和宏量营养素的重要来源。关于膳食补充剂(31%)和特定饮食(28%)的建议很常见,但很少有循证依据,而且常常相互矛盾。参与者发现很难辨别哪些建议是可信和可靠的。尽管如此,大多数人还是听从了建议。
大多数患者在首次就诊前接受了饮食和营养建议。这些建议大多来自非专业人士。任何来自非营养专业医疗保健人员的建议都是不一致或模糊的。这主要与避免和/或摄入某些特定食物有关,而且往往相互矛盾。然而,患者通常会完全遵循这些建议。为了帮助管理他们经常出现的营养相关症状并解决他们收到的相互矛盾的建议,许多人表示需要更早地接受专业的营养咨询。