Institute of Cardiovascular Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Liverpool Centre for Cardiovascular Science, University of Liverpool and Liverpool Heart & Chest Hospital, Liverpool, United Kingdom; Aalborg Thrombosis Research Unit, Department of Clinical Medicine, Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark.
Thromb Res. 2021 Apr;200:149-155. doi: 10.1016/j.thromres.2021.02.005. Epub 2021 Feb 9.
Direct oral anticoagulants (DOACs) are known to prevent thrombosis but there is limited information about their activity on the clot formation and lysis cascade.
This study assesses the role of apixaban, one of the four licenced DOACs, on clot dynamics in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF).
We compared haemostatic and clot lysis characteristics between a group of patients with AF (n = 47) and a "disease control" group with ischaemic heart disease but in sinus rhythm (n = 39). Subsequently, we conducted clot structure studies in 3 groups of patients with AF on different antithrombotic drugs: warfarin (n = 60), apixaban (n = 60) or antiplatelets (n = 62) and in patients with AF naïve to oral anticoagulants before and after 3-months treatment with apixaban (n = 32). Haemostasis was investigated by a viscoelastic, whole blood technique (Thromboelastography/TEG), a "microplate-reader based", citrated plasma technique (microplate assay), immunoassays to determine plasma concentrations of plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1), tissue-Plasminogen Activator (t-PA), D-dimer and finally platelet derived and apoptotic microparticles.
Patients with AF have more potent thrombogenesis based on microplate assay indices [Rate of clot formation (p = 0.03, ƞ = 0.06), Maximum optical density (p < 0.001, ƞ = 0.05)] and delayed fibrinolysis [Rate of clot dissolution (p = 0.005, ƞ = 0.17)] with increased levels of apoptotic microparticles (p = 0.02, ƞ = 0.06) compared with the 'disease control' group. Apixaban was more effective in attenuating prothrombotic characteristics assessed by TEG {R (ε = 0.21), K (ε = 0.16) and angle [mean difference (MD), 95% Confidence Intervals (CI), vs warfarin 5, 0.96-8.6 and 8, 3.8-11.4 vs antiplatelets], (p < 0.001 for all indices)} compared with the other treatment groups. Patients on apixaban had lower D-dimer (p < 0.001, ε = 0.17) and tPA (p = 0.03, MD 90, 95%CI 6-150 vs warfarin and MD 90, 95% CI 4-150 vs antiplatelets) levels. From the microplate assay analysis, warfarin and apixaban demonstrated comparable activity based on multiple indices, both superior to antiplatelets. However, warfarin was associated with reduced fibrin network robustness (Max. optical density p < 0.001, ε = 0.1). Apixaban inhibited thrombosis, amplified fibrinolysis and decreased D-dimer (p = 0.001, r = 0.4) levels in the follow up study.
Patients with AF have impaired haemostasis and elevated levels of apoptotic microparticles. Apixaban appears to affect plasma prothrombotic characteristics in a distinctive manner compared with warfarin and to reduce biomarkers associated with adverse cardiovascular events.
直接口服抗凝剂(DOACs)已知可预防血栓形成,但关于它们在血栓形成和纤溶级联反应中的活性的信息有限。
本研究评估了在房颤(AF)患者中,作为四种许可 DOAC 之一的阿哌沙班对血栓动力学的作用。
我们比较了房颤组(n=47)和缺血性心脏病但窦性节律组(n=39)之间的止血和血栓溶解特征。随后,我们在不同抗血栓药物的三组房颤患者中进行了血栓结构研究:华法林(n=60)、阿哌沙班(n=60)或抗血小板(n=62),以及在接受阿哌沙班治疗前和治疗 3 个月后无口服抗凝剂的房颤患者(n=32)。通过血栓弹性全血技术(血栓弹性图/TEG)、基于微孔板读数的柠檬酸血浆技术(微孔板测定法)、免疫测定法测定血浆纤溶酶原激活物抑制剂-1(PAI-1)、组织型纤溶酶原激活物(t-PA)、D-二聚体以及血小板衍生和凋亡微颗粒的浓度来评估止血情况。
与“疾病对照组”相比,房颤患者的血栓生成能力更强,基于微孔板测定法指标[形成速率(p=0.03,η=0.06)、最大光密度(p<0.001,η=0.05)]和纤溶延迟[溶解速率(p=0.005,η=0.17)],且凋亡微颗粒水平升高(p=0.02,η=0.06)。与其他治疗组相比,阿哌沙班在 TEG 评估的促血栓形成特征方面更有效{R(ε=0.21)、K(ε=0.16)和角度[平均差异(MD),95%置信区间(CI),与华法林相比,5、0.96-8.6 和 8、3.8-11.4,与抗血小板相比](p<0.001)}。与华法林和抗血小板相比,阿哌沙班的 D-二聚体(p<0.001,ε=0.17)和 tPA(p=0.03,MD 90,95%CI 6-150 vs 华法林和 MD 90,95%CI 4-150 vs 抗血小板)水平更低。从微孔板测定分析,华法林和阿哌沙班在多个指标上均表现出相当的活性,均优于抗血小板。然而,华法林与降低纤维蛋白网络稳定性相关(最大光密度 p<0.001,ε=0.1)。在随访研究中,阿哌沙班抑制血栓形成、放大纤溶作用并降低 D-二聚体(p=0.001,r=0.4)水平。
房颤患者的止血功能受损,凋亡微颗粒水平升高。与华法林相比,阿哌沙班似乎以独特的方式影响血浆促血栓形成特征,并降低与不良心血管事件相关的生物标志物。