Department of Epileptology, University Hospital Bonn, Venusberg Campus 1, 53127 Bonn, Germany.
Department of Epileptology, University Hospital Bonn, Venusberg Campus 1, 53127 Bonn, Germany.
Epilepsy Behav. 2021 Apr;117:107806. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2021.107806. Epub 2021 Feb 20.
This study investigated to which degree levetiracetam (LEV) and perampanel (PER), antiseizure medications (ASM) that are both known to cause aggression and irritability, share the same or different, behavioral side-effect profiles. In this self-report study, 68 participants with epilepsy treated with LEV (n = 35) or PER (n = 33) as part of their medication were asked to rate their behavioral experience with the respective drug as positive, neutral, or negative. Results of a German adaptation of the Adverse Events Profile (AEP) and of the "FPZ", a German personality questionnaire, were analyzed as a function of drug and rating. Thirty-eight percent of the LEV group and 36% of the PER group experienced negative change after the evaluated drug was introduced. By subdividing participants in the LEV sample into those who attributed the negative effects to LEV and those with neutral or positive experience with LEV, a negative evaluation of LEV was associated with significantly worse scores in cognition, mood, and physical domains (80% versus 20-40%). Subdividing participants in the PER sample into those who attributed negative the side effects to PER, and those with a neutral or positive experience with PER, significance could be shown for mood domains only (100% versus 50%), and within this domain only for increased aggression and irritability. Comparing features of the behavioral negative side effects of LEV and PER revealed that LEV appears to have a negative impact on a much broader range of behaviors than PER, which specifically seems to induce aggression and irritability and no other psychiatric side effects. Further research should aim at different expression and different mechanisms of aggression and irritability underlying the superficially similar effects of the two drugs.
本研究旨在探究抗癫痫药物左乙拉西坦(LEV)和吡仑帕奈(PER)在导致攻击性和易怒性这一行为副作用方面是否具有相同或不同的特征。在这项自我报告研究中,68 名接受 LEV(n=35)或 PER(n=33)治疗的癫痫患者被要求对各自药物的行为体验进行积极、中性或消极的评分。对德国版不良反应概况表(AEP)和德国人格问卷“FPZ”的结果进行了分析,其结果与药物和评分有关。38%的 LEV 组和 36%的 PER 组在评估药物引入后经历了负面变化。通过将 LEV 组中的参与者细分为将负面效应归因于 LEV 的参与者和对 LEV 有中性或积极体验的参与者,对 LEV 的负面评价与认知、情绪和身体领域的评分显著恶化(80%对 20-40%)有关。将 PER 组中的参与者细分为将负面副作用归因于 PER 的参与者和对 PER 有中性或积极体验的参与者,仅在情绪领域显示出显著性(100%对 50%),并且仅在该领域显示出攻击性和易怒性增加。比较 LEV 和 PER 的行为负性副作用的特征表明,LEV 似乎对更广泛的行为产生负面影响,而 PER 则特别容易引起攻击性和易怒性,而不会引起其他精神科副作用。进一步的研究应旨在探索两种药物表面相似的作用背后,攻击性和易怒性的不同表达和不同机制。