Department of Psychiatry, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY, USA.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2021 Feb;51(1):162-174. doi: 10.1111/sltb.12682.
Power analysis is critical for both planning future research samples and evaluating the reasonability of answers produced by pre-existing and fixed samples. Unfortunately, the irregularity of suicide-related data and the need for increasingly complex models in suicide research can make traditional power formulas inaccurate or even unusable. Ignoring these common problems risks both over- and under-recruiting, as well as obscuring the true quality of the results (up and down) to future reviewers and readers.
A better option is to use Monte Carlo power simulations.
These techniques produce answers that are equivalent to traditional power formulas when traditional assumptions are met, but produce more accurate results in the common case when those assumptions are violated.
What follows is a tutorial on how suicide researchers can conduct such simulations. It begins by building the reader's intuition for why simulations work, followed by two worked examples in R. Discussion also includes guidelines for conducting and reporting simulations, along with answers to frequently asked questions. Appendices provide code examples researchers can model and adapt to their own simulations as needed.
无论是规划未来研究样本还是评估现有固定样本产生答案的合理性,都需要进行功效分析。不幸的是,自杀相关数据的不规则性以及自杀研究中日益复杂的模型需求,使得传统的功效计算公式不准确甚至无法使用。忽视这些常见问题可能会导致样本招募过多或过少,以及对未来的评论者和读者隐瞒结果的真实质量(向上或向下)。
更好的选择是使用蒙特卡罗功效模拟。
当满足传统假设时,这些技术产生的答案与传统功效公式相当,但在违反这些假设的常见情况下,会产生更准确的结果。
以下是关于自杀研究人员如何进行此类模拟的教程。它首先为读者建立了对模拟为何有效的直觉理解,然后在 R 中提供了两个示例。讨论还包括关于进行和报告模拟的指南,以及对常见问题的解答。附录提供了研究人员可以建模并根据需要改编为自己的模拟的代码示例。