Jacoby Sara F, Robinson Andrew J, Webster Jessica L, Morrison Christopher N, Richmond Therese S
Department of Family and Community Health, School of Nursing, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
University of Pennsylvania Injury Science Center, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Mhealth. 2021 Jan 20;7:5. doi: 10.21037/mhealth-19-200. eCollection 2021.
Traumatic injuries are a health event that can begin a trajectory towards chronic health and social challenges. Mobile technology-based prevention and treatment interventions have been used to monitor and transform outcomes across a myriad of health conditions, but their potential in long-term injury recovery is unexplored. The goal of this pilot study was to assess the acceptability and feasibility of mobile health monitoring for long-term outcomes in a population of trauma patients with known barriers to health and social care after injury.
We re-recruited 25 individuals, 12-36 months after acute hospitalization, from a recently concluded study of psychological outcomes in seriously injured Black men in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. This mixed- methods pilot study was conducted in three phases: (I) qualitative interviews and development of a pilot monitoring platform; (II) a 3-month feasibility trial of mobile monitoring of patient-reported outcomes and biometric data using a wrist-worn commercial fitness monitor (n=18); (III) post-implementation qualitative interviews.
Analysis of data from pre-implementation interviews indicated that the majority of participants used smartphones as a primary means of communicating with their social network and to access the internet. The 90-day pilot trial of mobile monitoring indicated participants' preference text-delivered communication and survey elicitation. Response rates for 12 automated surveys ranged from 84-92%. Twenty-four hours a day adherence to optional biometric monitoring was generally lower than 50% but ranged widely indicating both very low adherence and very high adherence. Four of 25 participants, 2 who had opted for Fitbit monitoring, were lost to follow-up at the end of the 90-day pilot trial. In post-implementation assessments, participants endorsed the acceptability of mobile monitoring highlighting the benefit of its convenience and flexibility over in-person outcome monitoring. Participants also perceived its potential benefit in long-term engagement with health and social services to assist with the challenges they faced when attempting to achieve physical, psychological, social, and financial recovery after hospitalization. These findings were reinforced through qualitative interviews which highlighted, in addition to acceptability, the perceived value of self-monitoring through the use of wearable devices to track health data like physical activity and sleep.
This study indicates the feasibility and acceptability of mobile health monitoring used to examine long-term injury sequalae. Future research may leverage this novel strategy, refining its application to address current limitations in the reliability and accuracy of commercially available wearable technology, relative costs and benefits of different mobile data collection strategies, integration within current clinical paradigms and generalizability across injured populations and socio-ecological environments.
创伤性损伤是一种健康事件,可能引发一系列慢性健康和社会挑战。基于移动技术的预防和治疗干预措施已被用于监测和改善各种健康状况的结果,但其在长期损伤恢复中的潜力尚未得到探索。本试点研究的目的是评估移动健康监测在一群受伤后存在健康和社会护理障碍的创伤患者中对长期结果的可接受性和可行性。
我们从宾夕法尼亚州费城一项最近结束的关于严重受伤黑人男性心理结果的研究中,在急性住院12至36个月后重新招募了25名个体。这项混合方法试点研究分三个阶段进行:(I)定性访谈和试点监测平台的开发;(II)使用腕戴式商业健身监测器对患者报告的结果和生物特征数据进行3个月的移动监测可行性试验(n = 18);(III)实施后定性访谈。
实施前访谈数据分析表明,大多数参与者将智能手机作为与社交网络沟通和访问互联网的主要方式。移动监测的90天试点试验表明参与者更喜欢通过短信发送的通信和调查方式。12次自动调查的回复率在84%至92%之间。每天24小时对可选生物特征监测的依从性普遍低于50%,但范围差异很大,表明既有极低的依从性,也有极高的依从性。25名参与者中有4名,其中2名选择了Fitbit监测,在90天试点试验结束时失访。在实施后评估中,参与者认可移动监测的可接受性,强调其比亲自进行结果监测更方便和灵活的优点。参与者还认为它在与健康和社会服务的长期接触中具有潜在益处,有助于应对他们在住院后试图实现身体、心理、社会和经济恢复时所面临的挑战。这些发现通过定性访谈得到了加强,定性访谈除了强调可接受性外,还突出了通过使用可穿戴设备跟踪身体活动和睡眠等健康数据进行自我监测的感知价值。
本研究表明了用于检查长期损伤后遗症的移动健康监测的可行性和可接受性。未来的研究可以利用这一新颖策略,改进其应用,以解决当前商用可穿戴技术在可靠性和准确性方面的局限性、不同移动数据收集策略的相对成本和效益、在当前临床模式中的整合以及在受伤人群和社会生态环境中的可推广性。