Kennedy Ann Blair
University of South Carolina School of Medicine Greenville, Greenville, SC, USA.
Int J Ther Massage Bodywork. 2021 Mar 1;14(1):1-3. eCollection 2021 Mar.
Peer review is a mainstay of scientific publishing and, while peer reviewers and scientists report satisfaction with the process, peer review has not been without criticism. Within this editorial, the peer review process at the IJTMB is defined and explained. Further, seven steps are identified by the editors as a way to improve efficiency of the peer review and publication process. Those seven steps are: 1) Ask authors to submit possible reviewers; 2) Ask reviewers to update profiles; 3) Ask reviewers to "refer a friend"; 4) Thank reviewers regularly; 5) Ask published authors to review for the Journal; 6) Reduce the length of time to accept peer review invitation; and 7) Reduce requested time to complete peer review. We believe these small requests and changes can have a big effect on the quality of reviews and speed in which manuscripts are published. This manuscript will present instructions for completing peer review profiles. Finally, we more formally recognize and thank peer reviewers from 2018-2020.
同行评审是科学出版的支柱,虽然同行评审人员和科学家对这一过程表示满意,但同行评审并非没有受到批评。在本社论中,对《国际结核病与肺部疾病杂志》(IJTMB)的同行评审过程进行了定义和解释。此外,编辑们确定了七个步骤,作为提高同行评审和出版过程效率的一种方式。这七个步骤是:1)要求作者提交可能的评审人员名单;2)要求评审人员更新个人资料;3)要求评审人员“推荐朋友”;4)定期感谢评审人员;5)要求已发表文章的作者为该期刊进行评审;6)缩短接受同行评审邀请的时间;7)缩短完成同行评审所需的时间。我们相信,这些小小的要求和改变会对评审质量以及稿件发表速度产生重大影响。本文将介绍完成同行评审资料的说明。最后,我们更正式地认可并感谢2018年至2020年期间的同行评审人员。