Cook David L, Leya Ingo, Schönbächler Maria
Institute for Geochemistry and Petrology ETH Zürich Clausiusstrasse 25 8092 Zürich Switzerland.
Present address: Earth Observatory of Singapore 50 Nanyang Avenue Singapore 639798 Singapore.
Meteorit Planet Sci. 2020 Dec;55(12):2758-2771. doi: 10.1111/maps.13446. Epub 2020 Feb 11.
We present model calculations for cosmogenic production rates in order to quantify the potential effects of spallation and neutron capture reactions on Fe and Ni isotopes in iron meteorites. We aim to determine whether the magnitude of any cosmogenic effects on the isotopic ratios of Fe and/or Ni may hinder the search for nucleosynthetic variations in these elements or in the application of the Fe-Ni chronometer. The model shows that neutron capture reactions are the dominant source of shifts in Fe and Ni isotopic ratios and that spallation reactions are mostly negligible. The effects on Ni are sensitive to the Co/Ni ratio in the metal. The total galactic cosmic ray (GCR) effects on Ni and Ni can be minimized through the choice of normalizing isotopes (Ni/Ni versus Ni/Ni). In nearly all cases, the GCR effects (neutron capture and/or spallation) on Fe and Ni isotopic ratios are smaller than the current analytical resolution of the isotopic measurements. The model predictions are compared to the Fe and Ni isotopic compositions measured in a suite of six group IAB irons with a range of cosmic ray exposure histories. The experimental data are in good agreement with the model results. The minimal effects of GCRs on Fe and Ni isotopes should not hamper the search for nucleosynthetic variations in these two elements or the application of the Fe-Ni chronometer in iron meteorites or chondrites.
我们给出了宇宙成因产率的模型计算结果,以便量化散裂和中子俘获反应对铁陨石中Fe和Ni同位素的潜在影响。我们旨在确定宇宙成因效应对于Fe和/或Ni同位素比值的影响程度是否会阻碍对这些元素核合成变化的探寻,或者是否会影响Fe-Ni计时仪的应用。模型表明,中子俘获反应是Fe和Ni同位素比值发生变化的主要来源,而散裂反应的影响大多可以忽略不计。对Ni的影响对金属中的Co/Ni比值很敏感。通过选择归一化同位素(Ni/Ni与Ni/Ni之比),可以将总的银河宇宙射线(GCR)对Ni和Ni的影响降至最低。在几乎所有情况下,GCR(中子俘获和/或散裂)对Fe和Ni同位素比值的影响都小于目前同位素测量的分析分辨率。我们将模型预测结果与一组六块具有不同宇宙射线暴露历史的IAB群铁陨石中测量得到的Fe和Ni同位素组成进行了比较。实验数据与模型结果吻合良好。GCR对Fe和Ni同位素的影响极小,不应妨碍对这两种元素核合成变化的探寻,也不应影响Fe-Ni计时仪在铁陨石或球粒陨石中的应用。