Woolhandler S, Himmelstein D U
Department of Medicine, Cambridge Hospital, MA 02139.
JAMA. 1988 May 20;259(19):2872-4.
We analyzed patterns of receipt of preventive services among middle-aged women, with particular attention to health insurance coverage, based on data from the National Health Interview Survey. Lack of insurance was most prevalent among socioeconomically disadvantaged women at high risk for disease and was the strongest predictor of failure to receive screening tests. The relative risk of inadequate screening for uninsured compared with insured women was 1.60 (95% confidence interval [Cl], 1.40 to 1.83) for blood pressure checkups, 1.55 (95% Cl, 1.43 to 1.68) for cervical smears, 1.52 (95% Cl, 1.41 to 1.63) for glaucoma testing, and 1.42 (95% Cl, 1.33 to 1.51) for clinical breast examination. Controlling for demographic and health status variables did not diminish the effect of insurance coverage. We conclude that inadequate insurance coverage leads to "reverse targeting" of preventive care--that is, populations at highest risk are least likely to be screened. This compromises both the effectiveness and the cost-effectiveness of screening.
我们基于国家健康访谈调查的数据,分析了中年女性接受预防性服务的模式,尤其关注了医疗保险覆盖情况。在疾病高风险的社会经济弱势女性中,未参保情况最为普遍,并且是未能接受筛查检测的最强预测因素。与参保女性相比,未参保女性血压检查筛查不足的相对风险为1.60(95%置信区间[Cl],1.40至1.83),宫颈涂片为1.55(95% Cl,1.43至1.68),青光眼检测为1.52(95% Cl,1.41至1.63),临床乳房检查为1.42(95% Cl,1.33至1.51)。对人口统计学和健康状况变量进行控制并没有减弱保险覆盖的影响。我们得出结论,保险覆盖不足导致预防性保健出现“逆向靶向”——也就是说,风险最高的人群接受筛查的可能性最小。这损害了筛查的有效性和成本效益。