Bryce Jessica, Ndoja Silvio, Goyal Prateek, Lanting Brent, Howard James
Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry, Ontario, Canada.
Queen Elizabeth II Health Sciences Centre, Ontario, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2021 Feb 26;12(1):e21-e31. doi: 10.36834/cmej.57335. eCollection 2021 Feb.
Previous work suggests that patients do not understand the extent of resident involvement in their care and are also uncomfortable with resident involvement.
We recruited 202 English speaking patients with previous or planned total joint arthroplasty of the lower limb for a prospective survey trial. We assessed participant's knowledge of resident level of education and confidence of resident involvement in their surgery as a function of supervision.
Participants' mean level of confidence in the consultant surgeon was 4.30 (SD±1.13) on a 5-point Likert scale. Confidence in residents was significantly less, regardless of experience ( < 0.05). 11.1% of participants did not want residents involved in their treatment. 60.6% would like to know more about the education level of the trainee. Less than half of participants correctly identified the education level of residents and fellows.
Patient confidence in residents performing part or all of their surgery increases with resident experience and supervision. Compared with attending surgeons, patients have significantly less confidence in residents performing their surgery, including while supervised. Most patients do not understand the educational progression of medical trainees and would like to know more about the education level of the resident involved in their care. Further work should explore how we can help patients better understand resident involvement in their surgical care.
先前的研究表明,患者并不了解住院医师参与其治疗的程度,并且对住院医师的参与也感到不安。
我们招募了202名有过或计划进行下肢全关节置换术的英语患者,进行一项前瞻性调查试验。我们评估了参与者对住院医师教育水平的了解以及对住院医师在其手术中参与程度(作为监督的函数)的信心。
在5点李克特量表上,参与者对主刀医生的平均信心水平为4.30(标准差±1.13)。无论经验如何,对住院医师的信心明显较低(<0.05)。11.1%的参与者不希望住院医师参与他们的治疗。60.6%的人希望更多地了解实习医生的教育水平。不到一半的参与者正确识别了住院医师和研究员的教育水平。
患者对住院医师进行部分或全部手术的信心随着住院医师经验和监督的增加而增加。与主治医生相比,患者对住院医师进行手术的信心明显较低,包括在有监督的情况下。大多数患者不了解医学实习生的教育进程,希望更多地了解参与其治疗的住院医师的教育水平。进一步的工作应该探索如何帮助患者更好地理解住院医师参与其手术治疗的情况。