School of Social Work, 2331University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Gillings School of Global Public Health, 2331University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2022 Dec;23(5):1437-1460. doi: 10.1177/1524838021991310. Epub 2021 Mar 9.
Health and human service providers who aid traumatized individuals frequently experience vicarious trauma (VT). Although VT plays a critical role in service providers' mental health and well-being, as well as in the quality of their service provision, little information is available concerning the development and implementation of VT interventions for service providers. To advance the development of evidence in this area, we undertook a scoping review in which we reviewed existing interventions intended to address VT among service providers working with traumatized clients. Searches of electronic databases were conducted to identify studies published in peer-reviewed journals, with no date restrictions. Over 1,315 citations were reviewed, and a total of 27 studies were included in the final review. The findings show that VT interventions in the literature can be divided broadly into four categories: psychoeducation, mindfulness intervention, art and recreational programs, and alternative medicine therapy. The VT interventions reviewed generally showed promise in their key outcomes, including reductions in secondary trauma stress, compassion fatigue, burnout, and other mental health outcomes. However, the current body of research is lacking both in rigor and in specificity regarding the definition of VT. Furthermore, existing VT interventions are generally self-care based and tend to focus on general stress management rather than addressing the specific effects of VT. Therefore, we call for an increase in efforts to tailor VT interventions to different service settings and participant characteristics, as well as greater attention to developing primary VT interventions at the organizational level.
健康和人类服务提供者经常为创伤个体提供帮助,他们经常会经历替代性创伤(VT)。虽然 VT 对服务提供者的心理健康和幸福感以及服务提供的质量起着至关重要的作用,但关于针对服务提供者的 VT 干预措施的发展和实施的信息却很少。为了推动这一领域证据的发展,我们进行了范围界定审查,其中我们审查了旨在解决与创伤客户合作的服务提供者的 VT 问题的现有干预措施。对电子数据库进行了搜索,以确定在同行评议期刊上发表的研究,没有日期限制。共审查了 1315 多个引用,最终综述共纳入了 27 项研究。研究结果表明,文献中的 VT 干预措施可大致分为四类:心理教育、正念干预、艺术和娱乐项目以及替代医学疗法。审查的 VT 干预措施通常在其关键结果方面显示出希望,包括减少二次创伤压力、同情疲劳、倦怠和其他心理健康结果。然而,目前的研究在 VT 的定义方面既缺乏严谨性,也缺乏特异性。此外,现有的 VT 干预措施通常基于自我保健,往往侧重于一般的压力管理,而不是解决 VT 的具体影响。因此,我们呼吁加大努力,根据不同的服务环境和参与者特点调整 VT 干预措施,并更加关注在组织层面开发针对 VT 的初级干预措施。