Ribble C S, Jim G K, Janzen E D
Department of Herd Medicine and Theriogenology, Western College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon.
Can J Vet Res. 1988 Apr;52(2):191-8.
Two cohorts, consisting of 10,723 calves total, were identified in this prospective follow-up study to investigate whether immunization of auction market beef calves immediately upon arrival at the feedlot with a commercial Haemophilus somnus whole cell killed bacterin would reduce subsequent mortality. In addition to mortality rate, the use of incidence rate of fatal disease is introduced as an effect measure to examine vaccine efficacy in the feedlot. The Haemophilus somnus bacterin had no significant effect on the overall crude mortality rate; however, the bacterin appeared to significantly (p less than 0.05) reduce the incidence rate of fatal disease and the mortality rate during the first two months in the feedlot, when risk of fatal disease onset was highest. Once mortalities likely not associated with hemophilosis (for example, a fractured femoral neck) were removed from the analysis, steer mortality rate, but not heifer mortality rate, was reduced significantly (p less than 0.05) in the vaccinated group. The attributable percent overall for steers was 17.4%; this suggests that 17.4% of fatal respiratory disease in the unvaccinated steers could have been prevented by vaccination with the H. somnus bacterin. Heifer calves demonstrated a significantly (p less than 0.01) higher incidence rate of fatal disease during the first week than did steer calves, indicating that a different pattern of fatal disease existed for the two sexes. Use of a second vaccination two weeks after arrival did little to decrease mortality risk.
在这项前瞻性随访研究中,确定了两个队列,总共10723头犊牛,以调查在饲养场到达时立即用商业睡眠嗜血杆菌全细胞灭活菌苗对拍卖市场肉牛犊进行免疫接种是否会降低随后的死亡率。除了死亡率外,还引入了致命疾病发病率作为一种效应指标,以检验饲养场中疫苗的效力。睡眠嗜血杆菌菌苗对总体粗死亡率没有显著影响;然而,该菌苗似乎显著(p小于0.05)降低了致命疾病的发病率以及饲养场头两个月的死亡率,此时致命疾病发病风险最高。一旦将可能与嗜血杆菌病无关的死亡病例(例如,股骨颈骨折)从分析中去除,接种疫苗组的公牛死亡率显著降低(p小于0.05),但小母牛死亡率没有降低。公牛的总体归因百分比为17.4%;这表明,未接种疫苗的公牛中17.4%的致命呼吸道疾病可以通过接种睡眠嗜血杆菌菌苗预防。小母牛犊在第一周的致命疾病发病率显著(p小于0.01)高于公牛犊,表明两种性别的致命疾病模式不同。到达两周后进行第二次接种对接种疫苗组的死亡率降低几乎没有作用。