Björnsson S, Preisler H, Henderson E S
Med Pediatr Oncol. 1977;3(4):379-85. doi: 10.1002/mpo.2950030409.
Neutropenic cancer patients were given carbenicillin, cephalothin, and gentamicin (CCG) during 51 evaluable episodes of fever of unknown origin. Patients in whom fever persisted despite these antibiotics and in whom infection had not been documented were randomized after 3 days either to discontinue antibiotics or to add chloramphenicol or clindamycin to CCG. During 19 episodes (37%) an infection was documented during the first 3 days, and during an additional 12 episodes (24%) there was a response in 3 days without a focus of infection or an identifiable organism. Two patients died within 3 days, and one developed renal failure. Seventeen febrile episodes (33%) were unresponsive to CCG after 3 days and were randomized. Klebsiella was cultured in 4 of 6 patients randomized to stop antibiotics within a week of cessation, and 3 of these patients died. Of 11 episodes randomized to continue antibiotics, all patients were alive at 2 weeks after randomization and 9 after 4 weeks. This study, albeit small, demonstrates no advantage to withholding treatment in unremitting fever of unknown etiology and indeed strongly suggests that in this clinical setting, antibiotics once started should be continued until bone marrow recovery.
在51例可评估的不明原因发热的中性粒细胞减少癌症患者中给予羧苄青霉素、头孢噻吩和庆大霉素(CCG)。尽管使用了这些抗生素但仍持续发热且未记录到感染的患者,在3天后被随机分为两组,一组停用抗生素,另一组在CCG基础上加用氯霉素或克林霉素。在最初3天内有19例(37%)记录到感染,另有12例(24%)在3天内有反应但无感染灶或可识别的病原体。2例患者在3天内死亡,1例出现肾衰竭。17例发热发作(33%)在3天后对CCG无反应并被随机分组。在随机分组后一周内停用抗生素的6例患者中有4例培养出克雷伯菌,其中3例患者死亡。在随机分组继续使用抗生素的11例发作中,所有患者在随机分组后2周时存活,4周后9例存活。本研究尽管规模较小,但表明在不明病因的持续性发热中停止治疗没有优势,并且确实强烈提示在这种临床情况下,一旦开始使用抗生素就应持续使用直至骨髓恢复。