Melhem Jamal, Amarin Marzouq, Odeh Ghada, Al-Bustami Nadwa, Al-Lauzy Hatem, Ayoub Rami
Department of General Surgery.
Division of Breast Surgical Oncology.
Am J Clin Oncol. 2021 May 1;44(5):206-209. doi: 10.1097/COC.0000000000000809.
Whether to preserve or sacrifice the intercostobrachial nerves (ICBN) is a controversial issue. In this trial, we aim to assess the effects of preservation of the ICBN during axillary dissection for patients with breast cancer in terms of pain score immediately postoperatively and several hours later, need for simple analgesia and narcotics, numbness and arm swelling.
This is a single-institution, single-surgeon randomized controlled trial where a sample of 48 patients with breast cancer, of various age groups, were allocated randomly to any of the 2; preservation or sacrifice categories. Postoperatively, patients were asked by a physician to fill a predesigned questionnaire to assess the studied items during hospitalization and after discharge.
Among the 48 included patients, ICBN was sacrificed in 24 patients; of which 18 patients (75%) developed numbness in the inner aspect of the arm. While in the ICBN preservation group (24 patients) only 6 patients suffered numbness (25%) with a significant P-value of 0.001. Estimated duration of surgery with ICBN preservation was 100±22.02 minutes, while it is significantly shorter in the ICBN sacrifice group (83.48±21.55). However, with regard to other variables of pain, seroma formation, need of simple analgesia and narcotics, hospital admission days and arm swelling, there was no significant difference between the 2 groups.
This study can conclude that preservation of ICBN during axillary dissection in patients with breast CA can save these patients' additional suffering from inner arm numbness. That is at the expense of surgery duration, around 20 minutes longer, for the surgeon to take his/her time in carefully dissecting the axilla properly without injuring these ICBN.
保留还是牺牲肋间臂神经(ICBN)是一个存在争议的问题。在本试验中,我们旨在评估乳腺癌患者腋窝清扫术中保留ICBN对术后即刻及数小时后的疼痛评分、简单镇痛和使用麻醉剂的需求、麻木感及手臂肿胀情况的影响。
这是一项单机构、单术者的随机对照试验,48例不同年龄组的乳腺癌患者被随机分配到保留或牺牲ICBN这2组中的任意一组。术后,由医生要求患者填写预先设计的问卷,以评估住院期间和出院后的研究项目。
在纳入的48例患者中,24例患者的ICBN被牺牲;其中18例患者(75%)出现手臂内侧麻木。而在ICBN保留组(24例患者)中,只有6例患者出现麻木(25%),P值具有显著意义,为0.001。保留ICBN的手术估计时长为100±22.02分钟,而在ICBN牺牲组中显著更短(83.48±21.55)。然而,在疼痛、血清肿形成、简单镇痛和使用麻醉剂的需求、住院天数及手臂肿胀等其他变量方面,两组之间没有显著差异。
本研究可以得出结论,乳腺癌患者腋窝清扫术中保留ICBN可使患者免于额外遭受手臂内侧麻木之苦。这是以手术时长增加约20分钟为代价的,即外科医生需要花费更多时间仔细正确地解剖腋窝而不损伤这些ICBN。