Akgol Gur Sultan Tuna, Betos Kocak Meryem, Kocak Abdullah Osman, Vural Mert, Akbas Ilker, Dogruyol Sinem, Kerget Bugra, Cakir Zeynep
Department of Emergency Medicine, Ataturk University School of Medicine, Erzurum, Turkey.
Department of Family Medicine, Sukrupasa Family Health Center, Erzurum, Turkey.
Eurasian J Med. 2021 Feb;53(1):57-61. doi: 10.5152/eurasianjmed.2021.20341.
The most important problem for emergency physicians in patients presenting with chest pain is deciding whether to discharge the patient or not. Therefore, many scoring systems have been developed to help with this decision making process. We aim to achieve a modified HEART value by combining the VAS value with the HEART score.
Data were collected on age, sex, duration of the symptoms, pain severity using a 10-point visual analog scale (VAS), and the presence of a major adverse cardiac event (MACE). The HEART score was calculated and modified (mHEART) by adding 1 point to the total HEART score for a VAS score of ≥7.
During the study period, 4781 patients were admitted, and 293 participants were analyzed. Of the patients, 34(11.6%) experienced MACE within a month after the encounter. The mean VAS scores were 5.65±1.44. However, 77(26.3%) patients had VAS scores ≥7. Taking 3 as the threshold, 42(14.3%) patients had HEART scores of 4 and above, where 47(16.0%) had mHEART scores ≥4. The mHEART scoring demonstrated better test indicators than the HEART score. According to the HEART score, 6(2.3%) of the 251 patients predicted as negative would develop MACE, but this number decreased to 1(0.4%) in 246 using the mHEART score.
Although the HEART score performs reasonably well in discriminating patients who are MACE negative, it is possible to further improve the score by adding the VAS item. After validation by other studies, we would suggest modifying the HEART score by including the VAS item.
对于因胸痛前来就诊的患者,急诊医生面临的最重要问题是决定是否让患者出院。因此,已经开发了许多评分系统来辅助这一决策过程。我们旨在通过将视觉模拟量表(VAS)值与HEART评分相结合来实现改良的HEART值。
收集患者的年龄、性别、症状持续时间、使用10分视觉模拟量表(VAS)评估的疼痛严重程度以及是否存在重大不良心脏事件(MACE)等数据。计算HEART评分,并通过将VAS评分≥7时的HEART总分加1分来进行改良(mHEART)。
在研究期间,共收治4781例患者,分析了293例参与者。其中,34例(11.6%)患者在就诊后一个月内发生了MACE。VAS评分的平均值为5.65±1.44。然而,77例(26.3%)患者的VAS评分≥7。以3分为阈值,42例(14.3%)患者的HEART评分为4分及以上,其中47例(16.0%)患者的mHEART评分≥4。mHEART评分显示出比HEART评分更好的测试指标。根据HEART评分,251例预测为阴性的患者中有6例(2.3%)会发生MACE,但使用mHEART评分时,246例患者中这一数字降至1例(0.4%)。
尽管HEART评分在鉴别MACE阴性患者方面表现相当不错,但通过加入VAS项目有可能进一步提高该评分。在经过其他研究验证后,我们建议通过纳入VAS项目来改良HEART评分。