Zupanets Igor A, Dobrova Viktoriia Ye, Ratushna Kseniia L, Silchenko Sergii O
National University of Pharmacy, Kharkiv, Ukraine.
Inyurpolis Law Firm, Kharkiv, Ukraine.
Asian Bioeth Rev. 2018 Jul 21;10(2):105-121. doi: 10.1007/s41649-018-0057-9. eCollection 2018 Jul.
Open visiting policy (OVP) in intensive care units (ICU) is considered a favorable visiting regime that may benefit patients and their family members as well as medical staff. The article examines the conditions and causes of OVP-making process in Ukraine and presents the ethical analysis of its implications with respect to the key stakeholders: ICU patients, family members, and medical staff. The OVP, established by the Ministry of Health in June, 2016, changes current approaches to the recognition of the role of families in critically ill patients' care dramatically; it does, however, have serious shortcomings. The analysis of risks and benefits showed that OVP does not adequately cater to the needs of all the key players-family members, patients, and medical staff. Moreover, there is no clear mechanism to control OVP implementation via feedback from all the key players (particularly patients and their families). These issues give rise to a concern that the implementation of OVP will die on the vine. In order to prevent this, a range of measures is required: the optimization of the ICU facilities and internal procedures, supervision of OVP implementation by policy-makers, training of medical staff, and providing family members with educational programs. Considering current shortcomings, it is crucially important to develop clear and consistent internal guidelines in hospitals that will guarantee the introduction of open ICU visiting and quality of critical care provisions.
重症监护病房(ICU)的开放探视政策(OVP)被认为是一种有利的探视制度,可能使患者及其家属以及医护人员受益。本文研究了乌克兰制定开放探视政策的条件和原因,并对其对关键利益相关者(ICU患者、家属和医护人员)的影响进行了伦理分析。卫生部于2016年6月制定的开放探视政策极大地改变了目前对家庭在重症患者护理中作用的认识方式;然而,它确实存在严重缺陷。对风险和益处的分析表明,开放探视政策没有充分满足所有关键参与者(家属、患者和医护人员)的需求。此外,没有通过所有关键参与者(特别是患者及其家属)的反馈来控制开放探视政策实施的明确机制。这些问题引发了人们对开放探视政策实施将半途而废的担忧。为了防止这种情况发生,需要采取一系列措施:优化ICU设施和内部程序,政策制定者对开放探视政策实施情况进行监督,对医护人员进行培训,并为家属提供教育项目。考虑到当前的缺陷,在医院制定明确且一致的内部指导方针至关重要,这将确保开放ICU探视的引入以及重症护理服务的质量。