Department of Radiation Oncology, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Hematol Oncol. 2021 Aug;39(3):304-312. doi: 10.1002/hon.2865. Epub 2021 Mar 28.
National Comprehensive Cancer Network guidelines recommend radiation therapy (RT) for localized indolent non-Hodgkin lymphomas (iNHL). Many referring physicians avoid RT to the head and neck (HN) due to fears of toxicity. Very low-dose radiation (4 Gy) for select patients produces sustained local control and recently gained popularity. We compared early and late toxicities of standard 24-30 Gy to 4 Gy in patients with HN iNHL. We retrospectively analyzed 266 consecutive patients with HN iNHL receiving RT from 1994 to 2017. Patient characteristics, outcomes, and toxicities were collected from medical records. Early (≤2 months post-RT) and late (>2 months post-RT) toxicities were graded per Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events version 4. Grades 1-2 were defined as "low-grade" and 3-4 "high-grade." Toxicity incidence was compared between 4 and >4 Gy, grouped by treated site (orbit, nonorbital head, neck, skin) and early versus late. Median follow-up was 23 months (2-145) and 68 months (2-256) for 4Gy and >4 Gy cohorts, respectively. Median dose for the >4 Gy cohort was 30 Gy (10.5-54 Gy). Early and late toxicity incidences were lower in the 4 Gy cohort compared to >4 Gy across all RT-sites: early toxicity, orbit, 42% versus 96%; nonorbital head, 24% versus 96%; neck, 22% versus 94%; skin, 31% versus 87%; late toxicity, orbit, 20% versus 71%; nonorbital head, 6% versus 66%; neck, 6% versus 57%; skin, 0% versus 46% (4 Gy vs. >4 Gy, respectively). Toxicities among both cohorts were largely low-grade. High-grade early and late toxicities did not occur in the 4 Gy cohort. There was 1 high-grade early toxicity (Grade 3 dry mouth) and 17 high-grade late toxicities (Grade 3 cataracts) in the >4 Gy cohort. RT to HN for iNHL is associated with minimal short- and long-term toxicity and excellent local control among 4 Gy and >4 Gy treatments. In this setting, "toxicity" concerns should not deter oncologists from potentially curative RT. In select patients where toxicity remains a concern, very low dose 4 Gy could be considered.
美国国家综合癌症网络指南建议对局限性惰性非霍奇金淋巴瘤(iNHL)进行放射治疗(RT)。由于担心毒性,许多转诊医生避免对头颈部(HN)进行 RT。对于某些患者,采用非常低剂量的辐射(4Gy)可实现持续的局部控制,最近受到了广泛关注。我们比较了 HN iNHL 患者接受标准 24-30Gy 与 4Gy 治疗的早期和晚期毒性。我们回顾性分析了 1994 年至 2017 年期间接受 RT 的 266 例 HN iNHL 连续患者。从病历中收集患者特征、结局和毒性。根据不良事件常用术语标准第 4 版对早期(RT 后≤2 个月)和晚期(RT 后>2 个月)毒性进行分级。1-2 级定义为“低级别”,3-4 级为“高级别”。根据治疗部位(眼眶、非眼眶头部、颈部、皮肤)和早期与晚期,将 4Gy 和>4Gy 组之间的毒性发生率进行比较。4Gy 和>4Gy 队列的中位随访时间分别为 23 个月(2-145)和 68 个月(2-256)。>4Gy 队列的中位剂量为 30Gy(10.5-54Gy)。与>4Gy 相比,4Gy 组在所有 RT 部位的早期和晚期毒性发生率均较低:早期毒性,眼眶,42%比 96%;非眼眶头部,24%比 96%;颈部,22%比 94%;皮肤,31%比 87%;晚期毒性,眼眶,20%比 71%;非眼眶头部,6%比 66%;颈部,6%比 57%;皮肤,0%比 46%(4Gy 比>4Gy,分别)。两个队列的毒性主要为低级别。4Gy 队列未发生高等级的早期和晚期毒性。>4Gy 队列中有 1 例高等级早期毒性(3 级口干)和 17 例高等级晚期毒性(3 级白内障)。对于 iNHL 的 HN RT 与 4Gy 和>4Gy 治疗相关,具有最小的短期和长期毒性和极好的局部控制。在这种情况下,“毒性”问题不应阻止肿瘤学家对潜在的根治性 RT 望而却步。对于那些仍存在毒性问题的患者,可考虑采用非常低剂量的 4Gy。