I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University (Sechenov University), Moscow, Russia.
Kardiologiia. 2021 Feb 10;61(1):52-58. doi: 10.18087/cardio.2021.1.n1423.
Aim To determine levels of markers for endothelial dysfunction and inflammation, endothelin-1, E-selectin, and tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α) in patients with ischemic heart disease (IHD) and non-obstructive and obstructive coronary artery (CA) disease.Material and methods This study included 32 patients with verified IHD and non-obstructive (main group, n=19) and obstructive (comparison group, n=13) CA disease. Endothelial dysfunction was diagnosed by photoplethysmography and videocapillaroscopy. Serum concentrations of endothelin-1, E-selectin, and TNF- α were measured in all patients.Results Patients with non-obstructive CA disease showed a tendency towards more pronounced endothelial dysfunction (alternative stiffness index, 7.8 m /s [6.35; 9.08]; reflection index, 36.95 % [23.4; 52.65]; capillary density following reactive hyperemia, 54.33 cap /mm2 [48.92; 75.83]; capillary density following venous occlusion, 74.33 cap /mm2 [67.83; 93.00]) compared to the comparison group (alternative stiffness index, 9.05 m/s [7.08; 10.58]; reflection index, 28.25 % [23.35; 53.75]; capillary density following reactive hyperemia, 66.83 cap /mm2 [50.83; 78.67]; capillary density following venous occlusion, 87.0 cap /mm2 [77.58; 78.67]), although statistically significant differences were not found. Concentration of endothelin-1 was significantly higher in the IHD group with non-obstructive CA disease (0.45 ng/ml [0.28;0.65]) compared to patients with CA atherosclerotic stenosis (0.35 ng/ml [0.25; 0.38], p=0.035). Concentrations of E-selectin did not significantly differ between the groups (main group, 21.1 ng/ml [18.45; 35.03]; comparison group, 28.55 ng/ml [19.08; 35.01], p=0.29). In both groups, concentrations of TNF-α did not exceed the lower threshold of sensitivity (<2.3 pg/ml).Conclusion Endothelial dysfunction and increased endothelin-1 in patients with non-obstructive CA disease along with inflammation may additionally contribute to the pathogenesis of IHD in the absence of hemodynamically significant CA stenoses. Too low level of TNFα in both groups prevented us from using it as a diagnostic marker. Further study is needed that would include a greater number of patients and a search for alternative markers.
确定内皮功能障碍和炎症标志物,内皮素-1、E-选择素和肿瘤坏死因子α(TNF-α)在缺血性心脏病(IHD)和非阻塞性及阻塞性冠状动脉(CA)疾病患者中的水平。
本研究纳入了 32 名确诊为 IHD 且伴有非阻塞性(主要组,n=19)和阻塞性(对照组,n=13)CA 疾病的患者。通过光体积描记术和视频毛细血管镜诊断内皮功能障碍。所有患者均测量血清内皮素-1、E-选择素和 TNF-α浓度。
与对照组相比(替代僵硬指数 9.05 m/s [7.08; 10.58];反射指数 28.25% [23.35; 53.75];反应性充血后毛细血管密度 66.83 个/mm2 [50.83; 78.67];静脉闭塞后毛细血管密度 87.0 个/mm2 [77.58; 78.67]),非阻塞性 CA 疾病患者的内皮功能障碍倾向更为明显(替代僵硬指数 7.8 m/s [6.35; 9.08];反射指数 36.95% [23.4; 52.65];反应性充血后毛细血管密度 54.33 个/mm2 [48.92; 75.83];静脉闭塞后毛细血管密度 74.33 个/mm2 [67.83; 93.00]),但差异无统计学意义。非阻塞性 CA 疾病的 IHD 患者的内皮素-1 浓度明显高于伴有 CA 粥样硬化狭窄的患者(0.45 ng/ml [0.28;0.65] 比 0.35 ng/ml [0.25; 0.38],p=0.035)。两组间 E-选择素浓度无显著差异(主要组 21.1 ng/ml [18.45; 35.03];对照组 28.55 ng/ml [19.08; 35.01],p=0.29)。两组患者的 TNF-α浓度均未超过较低的检测阈值(<2.3 pg/ml)。
非阻塞性 CA 疾病患者存在内皮功能障碍和内皮素-1升高,以及炎症反应,这可能与不伴有血流动力学意义重大的 CA 狭窄的 IHD 发病机制有关。两组患者的 TNF-α水平均过低,无法将其作为诊断标志物。需要进一步研究,纳入更多患者,并寻找替代标志物。