Sharma Dhiraj, Thahir Azeem, Sharma Vivek, Krkovic Matjia
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedics, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, GBR.
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedics, Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals Foundation Trust, Norwich, GBR.
Cureus. 2021 Feb 12;13(2):e13311. doi: 10.7759/cureus.13311.
Complex tibial plateau fractures (TPFs) represent a significant treatment challenge for any Orthopaedic surgeon. Current literature suggests that significantly displaced TPFs in the elderly require operative fixation, an operation that is associated with serious complications including septic and post-operative arthritis. As a result, these patients are five times more likely to require a total knee replacement (TKR). We present a case series of five elderly patients with complex TPFs who made serendipitous recoveries while awaiting operations. Their fractures were deemed so severe that they were being considered for TKR instead of fixation. We discovered their surprising functional improvements while they were being reviewed pre-operatively and decided to delay operating. We are currently unaware of any cases in the literature that have reported such findings. In total, five patients presented in 2019 with closed, varus/valgus stable fractures. They were managed non-operatively in hinged-knee braces, progressively weight-bearing with a minimum follow-up of 10 months. Oxford Knee Scores (OKS) were recorded at zero and four months after their injury. All patients were female with an average age of 69 years. Average fracture depression - 8.48mm, average fracture split - 8.66mm, average OKS reduction - 19%. All patients were able to mobilise independently at four months follow-up. Our results suggest that non-operative management can be considered as primary management in elderly patients with significantly displaced TPFs. Should this fail, or they develop arthritis, a TKR can be performed. This carries two benefits: the patient avoids the significant complications associated with fixation and should a TKR be required, it can more easily be performed in a patient without metalwork in-situ. We feel that the results from this case series might offer insight into a new treatment strategy and continue to closely follow these patients.
复杂胫骨平台骨折(TPF)对任何骨科医生来说都是一项重大的治疗挑战。目前的文献表明,老年患者中明显移位的TPF需要手术固定,而该手术会引发包括感染性关节炎和术后关节炎在内的严重并发症。因此,这些患者进行全膝关节置换(TKR)的可能性要高出五倍。我们报告了一组五例患有复杂TPF的老年患者,他们在等待手术期间意外康复。他们的骨折被认为非常严重,原本考虑进行TKR而非固定手术。我们在术前复查时发现了他们令人惊讶的功能改善,于是决定推迟手术。目前我们尚未在文献中发现有报道此类结果的病例。2019年共有五例患者,均为闭合性、内翻/外翻稳定骨折。他们采用带铰链的膝关节支具进行非手术治疗,逐步负重,最短随访时间为10个月。在受伤后零个月和四个月记录牛津膝关节评分(OKS)。所有患者均为女性,平均年龄69岁。平均骨折塌陷8.48毫米,平均骨折劈裂8.66毫米,平均OKS改善19%。所有患者在随访四个月时均能独立活动。我们的结果表明,对于明显移位的老年TPF患者,非手术治疗可被视为首选治疗方法。如果这种方法失败,或者患者发展为关节炎,则可进行TKR。这样做有两个好处:患者可避免与固定相关的严重并发症,并且如果需要进行TKR,在体内没有金属植入物的患者身上进行手术会更容易。我们认为该病例系列的结果可能为一种新的治疗策略提供见解,并将继续密切随访这些患者。