UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway.
FernUniversität in Hagen, Hagen, Germany.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2021 Oct;60(4):1330-1349. doi: 10.1111/bjso.12454. Epub 2021 Mar 19.
Is there a 'more helpful' gender? The present research assessed gender differences in prosocial self-perceptions, prosocial behavioural intentions, and prosocial (transfer) behaviour in same- and other-gender interactions in 10 countries (N = 1,915). The present results showed negligible differences in the degree to which women and men saw themselves as prosocial. However, larger gender differences emerged in regard to prosocial behavioural intentions and prosocial (transfer) behaviours across different help contexts (i.e., same- vs. other-gender interactions). In a hypothetical work scenario, women reported greater prosocial behavioural intentions than men when the recipient of the help was of the same gender. In contrast, when the recipient of the help was of the other gender, men reported greater prosocial behavioural intentions than women. In addition, men transferred more than women to both same- and other-gender interaction partners in a prisoner's dilemma game. Taken together, the present findings suggest that there is no 'more helpful' gender. Instead, gender differences in prosociality are dynamic and contextual. Different theoretical perspectives are taken into consideration in discussing gender differences in the present research.
是否存在“更乐于助人”的性别?本研究评估了 10 个国家(N=1915)中在相同性别和不同性别互动中亲社会自我认知、亲社会行为意图和亲社会(转移)行为方面的性别差异。本研究结果表明,男女在自我感知的亲社会性程度方面几乎没有差异。然而,在不同的帮助情境(即相同性别与不同性别互动)中,亲社会行为意图和亲社会(转移)行为方面出现了更大的性别差异。在一个假设的工作场景中,当帮助的接受者是同性别的时候,女性比男性报告了更大的亲社会行为意图。相比之下,当帮助的接受者是异性时,男性比女性报告了更大的亲社会行为意图。此外,在囚徒困境游戏中,男性向同性和异性互动伙伴的转移都比女性多。总之,本研究结果表明,没有“更乐于助人”的性别。相反,亲社会性方面的性别差异是动态的和情境化的。本研究从不同的理论视角探讨了亲社会性方面的性别差异。