Baqai Medical University, Karachi, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan.
PCSIR, Labs Complex, Karachi, Pakistan.
J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2020 Oct-Dec;32(Suppl 1)(4):S672-S677.
Conventional heat cure polymerized acrylic resin(unmodified) is most acceptable denture base material in dentistry since decades. It has been modified with reinforcement of fillers and different processing techniques were introduced to enhance its mechanical and physical properties. The objective of this research is to determine and compare the effect of different processing techniques on flexural strength of modified and unmodified denture base acrylic resin. Air circulating oven is introduced for the first time in this study and its efficacy is also compared with other conventional processing techniques.
In this study total number of 114 rectangular specimens were fabricated by conventional heat cured acrylic (Stellon QC 20, Dentsply) for Group A (n=57), and rubber reinforced acrylic resin (High impact, Meadway) for Group B (n=57). Three equipment including water bath, dry oven and air circulating oven were utilized for processing specimens individually. Each sub-group of processing techniques (n=19) were tested for flexural strength through a three-point bending test by a universal testing machine. The statistical analysis initiated with descriptive analysis followed by independent t test for mean comparison of flexural strength of all three processing techniques among both testing group. One-way ANOVA and 2-way ANOVA followed by Scheffe post hoc test were also applied. p-value of 0.05 or less was considered as significant.
Statically significant p-value <0.001 was found in response of flexural strength in all processing techniques (water bath, dry oven, air circulating oven) of both testing groups. Water bath processing demonstrated highest flexural strength values in both denture base material used in this study. The unit used for flexural strength was MPa.
This study manifested highest flexural strength in conventional and rubber reinforced heat cure samples when processed through water bath. Air circulating oven also presented acceptable flexural strength in conventional heat cure acrylic resin specimens when compared with other techniques.
几十年来,传统的热固性聚合丙烯酸树脂(未改性)一直是牙科中最受欢迎的义齿基托材料。它已经通过增强填料进行了改性,并引入了不同的加工技术来提高其机械和物理性能。本研究的目的是确定和比较不同加工技术对改性和未改性义齿基托丙烯酸树脂弯曲强度的影响。本研究首次引入了空气循环烘箱,并将其与其他常规加工技术进行了比较。
本研究共制作了 114 个矩形试件,其中 57 个试件采用常规热固化丙烯酸树脂(Stellon QC 20,Dentsply)制成,57 个试件采用橡胶增强丙烯酸树脂(High impact,Meadway)制成。分别采用水浴、干烤箱和空气循环烘箱三种设备对试件进行加工。每组加工技术(n=19)分别通过三点弯曲试验用万能试验机测试弯曲强度。统计分析首先进行描述性分析,然后对两组测试中所有三种加工技术的弯曲强度进行独立 t 检验。还应用了单因素方差分析和双因素方差分析,随后进行了 Scheffe 事后检验。p 值小于 0.05 被认为具有统计学意义。
两组测试中所有加工技术(水浴、干烤箱、空气循环烘箱)的弯曲强度均有统计学意义(p<0.001)。水浴处理在本研究中使用的两种义齿基托材料中均表现出最高的弯曲强度值。弯曲强度的单位为 MPa。
本研究表明,在传统和橡胶增强热固性样品中,通过水浴处理可获得最高的弯曲强度。与其他技术相比,空气循环烘箱在传统热固性丙烯酸树脂样品中也可获得可接受的弯曲强度。