Department of Psychology, Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science, North Chicago, IL, USA.
Departments of Psychiatry, Surgery, and Psychology, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
Am J Mens Health. 2021 Mar-Apr;15(2):15579883211001198. doi: 10.1177/15579883211001198.
Most obesity prevalence data rely on self-report, which typically differs when compared to objectively measured height, weight, and body mass index (BMI). Given that Latino men have high rates of obesity in the United States and demonstrate greater misreporting compared to Caucasian men, examining the factors that contribute to misreporting among Latino men is warranted. This study examined BMI, Latino ethnic background (Mexican or Puerto Rican), and social desirability in relation to misreporting of BMI, as defined as the discrepancy between self-reported and measured height and weight, in Latino men. Participants were 203 adult Mexican and Puerto Rican men, average age 39.41 years, who participated in a larger study. Participants self-reported their weight and height, had their weight and height objectively measured, and completed a measure of social desirability. Measured BMI was the strongest predictor of misreporting BMI, such that the greater the participants' BMI, the greater the discrepancy in BMI ( < .001). Misreporting of BMI did not vary based on ethnic background, and measured BMI did not moderate the relationship between social desirability and misreporting of BMI. When normative error was distinguished from misreporting in post-hoc analyses, results showed that only 34.5% of participants demonstrated misreporting. Findings highlight the importance of identifying normative error when examining misreporting in order to improve the accuracy of self-reported BMI data. Future research on misreporting for Latino men should include weight awareness, acculturation, and length of U.S. residency as these variables may be related to self-reported weight and height.
大多数肥胖患病率数据依赖于自我报告,而自我报告的数据通常与客观测量的身高、体重和体重指数(BMI)存在差异。鉴于美国拉丁裔男性的肥胖率较高,且与白种男性相比,他们的报告误差更大,因此有必要研究导致拉丁裔男性报告误差的因素。本研究探讨了 BMI、拉丁裔族裔背景(墨西哥裔或波多黎各裔)和社会期望与 BMI 报告误差之间的关系,BMI 报告误差定义为自我报告的身高和体重与实际测量的身高和体重之间的差异。参与者为 203 名成年墨西哥裔和波多黎各裔男性,平均年龄 39.41 岁,他们参与了一项更大的研究。参与者自我报告体重和身高,身高和体重由研究人员进行客观测量,并完成了社会期望测量。测量的 BMI 是 BMI 报告误差的最强预测因素,即参与者的 BMI 越高,BMI 差异越大(<.001)。BMI 报告误差与族裔背景无关,测量的 BMI 也不能调节社会期望与 BMI 报告误差之间的关系。在事后分析中区分规范误差与报告误差后,结果显示只有 34.5%的参与者存在报告误差。研究结果强调,在检查 BMI 自我报告数据的报告误差时,识别规范误差的重要性,以提高自我报告 BMI 数据的准确性。未来针对拉丁裔男性的报告误差研究应包括体重意识、文化适应和在美国居住的时间长短,因为这些变量可能与自我报告的体重和身高有关。