Main General Practice Surgery, Strasbourg, France.
Department of Integrative Medicine, Saint Vincent Hospital Group, Toussaint Hospital, Strasbourg, France.
Support Care Cancer. 2021 Oct;29(10):5873-5881. doi: 10.1007/s00520-021-06137-5. Epub 2021 Mar 24.
In France, homeopathy is the most frequently used complementary therapy in supportive care in oncology (SCO); its use is steadily increasing. However, data is limited about the perception and relevance of homeopathy by oncologists and general practitioners (GPs) both with and without homeopathic training (HGPs and NHGPs, respectively). Our aim was to evaluate French physicians' perceptions of homeopathy to clarify its place in SCO through two original observation survey-based studies.
Two cross-sectional surveys of French physicians were conducted involving (1) 150 specialist oncologists; (2) 97 HGPs and 100 NHGPs. Questions evaluated physician attitudes to homeopathy and patterns of use of homeopathic therapies in patients requiring SCO. Survey responses were described and analyzed on the basis of physician status.
Ten percent of oncologists stated they prescribe homeopathy; 36% recommend it; 54% think that homeopathy is potentially helpful in SCO. Two-thirds of the NHGPs sometimes prescribe homeopathy in the context of SCO and 58% regularly refer their patients to homeopathic doctors. HGPs have a positive perception of homeopathy in SCO.
Homeopathy is viewed favorably as an integrated SCO therapy by the majority of French physicians involved with cancer patients-oncologists and GPs. Symptoms of particular relevance include fatigue, anxiety, peripheral neuropathy, sleep disturbance, and hot flashes. In such clinical situations, response to conventional therapies may be suboptimal and homeopathy is considered a reliable therapeutic option. These two studies highlight the fact that homeopathy has gained legitimacy as the first complementary therapy in SCO in France.
在法国,顺势疗法是肿瘤支持治疗(SCO)中最常使用的补充疗法;其使用量稳步增加。然而,关于肿瘤学家和普通科医生(GP)对顺势疗法的看法和相关性的数据有限,包括接受过顺势疗法培训(HGPs 和 NHGPs)和未接受过顺势疗法培训的医生。我们的目的是通过两项基于原始观察调查的研究来评估法国医生对顺势疗法的看法,以明确其在 SCO 中的地位。
对法国医生进行了两项横断面调查,涉及(1)150 名肿瘤专科医生;(2)97 名 HGPs 和 100 名 NHGPs。问题评估了医生对顺势疗法的态度以及在需要 SCO 的患者中使用顺势疗法治疗的模式。根据医生的身份,对调查结果进行了描述和分析。
10%的肿瘤学家表示他们开顺势疗法处方;36%的人推荐;54%的人认为顺势疗法在 SCO 中具有潜在的帮助。三分之二的 NHGPs 在 SCO 背景下有时会开顺势疗法处方,58%的人定期将患者转介给顺势疗法医生。HGPs 对 SCO 中的顺势疗法有积极的看法。
大多数参与癌症患者治疗的法国医生,包括肿瘤学家和 GP,都认为顺势疗法是一种有利的 SCO 治疗方法。特别相关的症状包括疲劳、焦虑、周围神经病变、睡眠障碍和热潮红。在这种临床情况下,对常规疗法的反应可能不理想,因此顺势疗法被认为是一种可靠的治疗选择。这两项研究强调了顺势疗法在法国作为 SCO 中第一种补充疗法已获得合法性的事实。