School of Dental Sciences, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Newcastle upon Tyne Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Dent Traumatol. 2021 Aug;37(4):608-616. doi: 10.1111/edt.12676. Epub 2021 Mar 31.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Primary care dentists play a pivotal role in the management of traumatic dental injuries in children, despite little evidence on the barriers they face in providing care. The aim of this study was to explore and contextualize the knowledge and attitudes of general dental practitioners regarding their management of permanent dentition traumatic dental injuries in children aged 7-16 years old.
A two-phase sequential mixed-methods study included a questionnaire that was disseminated to all 619 primary care dentists, identified via a triangulated sampling strategy, based across the north-east of England (Phase I). Statistical analyses were performed using Mann-Whitney U- and Kruskal-Wallis tests, Spearman's correlation and chi-square test. Multivariate factor analysis, with principal components extraction, was used to test between multiple ordinal variables. Respondents were invited to a face-to-face or telephone semi-structured interview (Phase II). Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed using inductive thematic analysis.
Primary care dentists were less confident in managing complex dental trauma. Inadequate financial remuneration was the main reason for not providing care, often prompting a referral to the local dental hospital. This was more apparent for those who qualified before 2000. More recently qualified dentists felt the long-term costs, related to traumatic dental injuries, were insufficiently remunerated. Most still provided emergency management, irrespective of remuneration, as long as they had the requisite knowledge and skills. Four major themes arose: impact of traumatic dental injuries on patients, parents and primary care dentists; barriers to providing treatment; educational opportunities for primary care dentists; and interactions between primary and secondary care services.
There is high confidence in managing simple traumatic dental injuries but less for complex injuries. A lack of sufficient financial remuneration associated with the long-term management of dental trauma was the main barrier for dentists to manage these cases.
背景/目的:尽管针对儿童创伤性牙外伤管理方面,基层口腔医生所面临的障碍相关证据有限,但他们在儿童创伤性牙外伤的管理中发挥着关键作用。本研究旨在探讨和分析普通牙科医生对 7-16 岁儿童恒牙创伤性牙外伤管理的知识和态度。
本研究采用两阶段序贯混合方法,第一阶段通过基于英格兰东北部的三角抽样策略确定了 619 名基层口腔医生,并向其发放了问卷;第二阶段邀请了对问卷做出回复的医生进行面对面或电话半结构式访谈。统计分析采用 Mann-Whitney U 检验、Kruskal-Wallis 检验、Spearman 相关检验和卡方检验。采用多元因子分析和主成分提取对多个有序变量进行检验。
基层口腔医生对复杂牙科创伤的管理信心不足。缺乏足够的经济报酬是不提供治疗的主要原因,这往往促使他们将患者转介到当地的牙科医院。对于那些在 2000 年之前获得资格认证的医生来说,这种情况更为明显。最近获得资格认证的医生认为,与创伤性牙外伤相关的长期成本没有得到充分补偿。只要他们具备必要的知识和技能,大多数医生仍会提供紧急管理,无论报酬如何。研究结果主要包括四个主题:创伤性牙外伤对患者、家长和基层口腔医生的影响;治疗障碍;基层口腔医生的教育机会;以及基层和二级保健服务之间的相互作用。
基层口腔医生对简单创伤性牙外伤的管理信心较高,但对复杂创伤性牙外伤的管理信心较低。缺乏足够的经济报酬以及与长期管理牙科创伤相关的费用是基层口腔医生管理这些病例的主要障碍。