Wang Meizi, Jiang Ci, Fekete Gusztáv, Teo Ee-Chon, Gu Yaodong
Faculty of Sports Science, Ningbo University, Ningbo, China.
Faculty of Engineering, University of Pannonia, Veszprem, Hungary.
Appl Bionics Biomech. 2021 Mar 12;2021:6618581. doi: 10.1155/2021/6618581. eCollection 2021.
Effective recommendations about how to decrease adverse effects of high heels (HH) need to be provided, since wearing HH is inevitable for most women in their daily life, regardless of their negative impacts on the foot morphology. The main purpose of this systematic review was to summarize studies which have provided specific information about how to effectively offset the negative effects of wearing HH, in the case of women, by means of examining heel height, insole, and heel base support (HBS). Some evidence indicate the following: (i) the range of appropriate heel height for HH shoes is 3.76 cm to 4.47 cm; (ii) compared to small HBS, the larger ones effectively increase gait stability, reduce risk of ankle injury, and improve comfort rating during HH walking; and (iii) the use of a total contact insert (TCI) significantly decreases plantar pressure and the impact on the foot, resulting in higher perceived comfort. It must be noted that these results are based on short-term research; therefore, any conclusions with regard to effects in the long term should be taken with a grain of salt. Nevertheless, future studies should be aimed at combining numerical and experimental methods, in order to provide personal recommendations for HH shoes by considering heel height and HBS size, based on the individual characters (weight, height, and age).
由于高跟鞋对足部形态有负面影响,但对大多数女性来说,在日常生活中穿高跟鞋不可避免,因此需要提供关于如何减少高跟鞋负面影响的有效建议。本系统评价的主要目的是总结相关研究,这些研究通过检查鞋跟高度、鞋垫和鞋跟基部支撑(HBS),提供了有关如何有效抵消女性穿高跟鞋负面影响的具体信息。一些证据表明:(i)高跟鞋的合适鞋跟高度范围是3.76厘米至4.47厘米;(ii)与较小的HBS相比,较大的HBS能有效提高步态稳定性,降低脚踝受伤风险,并改善穿高跟鞋行走时的舒适度评分;(iii)使用全接触鞋垫(TCI)可显著降低足底压力和对足部的影响,从而带来更高的舒适度。必须指出的是,这些结果基于短期研究;因此,任何关于长期影响的结论都应持保留态度。尽管如此,未来的研究应致力于结合数值方法和实验方法,以便根据个人特征(体重、身高和年龄),通过考虑鞋跟高度和HBS尺寸,为高跟鞋提供个性化建议。