Sharwood Lisa N, Whyatt David, Vaikuntam Bharat P, Cheng Christiana L, Noonan Vanessa K, Joseph Anthony P, Ball Jonathon, Stanford Ralph E, Kok Mei-Ruu, Withers Samuel R, Middleton James W
Sydney Medical School, Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney, Reserve Road, St Leonards, NSW, 2065, Australia.
University of New South Wales, Faculty of Medicine and Health, NSW Black Dog Institute, Sydney, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2021 Apr 1;21(1):292. doi: 10.1186/s12913-021-06235-4.
Timely treatment is essential for achieving optimal outcomes after traumatic spinal cord injury (TSCI), and expeditious transfer to a specialist spinal cord injury unit (SCIU) is recommended within 24 h from injury. Previous research in New South Wales (NSW) found only 57% of TSCI patients were admitted to SCIU for acute post-injury care; 73% transferred within 24 h from injury. We evaluated pre-hospital and inter-hospital transfer practices to better understand the post-injury care pathways impact on patient outcomes and highlight areas in the health service pathway that may benefit from improvement.
This record linkage study included administrative pre-hospital (Ambulance), admissions (Admitted Patients) and costs data obtained from the Centre for Health Record Linkage, NSW. All patients aged ≥16 years with incident TSCI in NSW (2013-2016) were included. We investigated impacts of geographical disparities on pre-hospital and inter-hospital transport decisions from injury location using geospatial methods. Outcomes assessed included time to SCIU, surgery and the impact of these variables on the experience of inpatient complications.
Inclusion criteria identified 316 patients, geospatial analysis showed that over half (53%, n = 168) of all patients were injured within 60 min road travel of a SCIU, yet only 28.6% (n = 48) were directly transferred to a SCIU. Patients were more likely to experience direct transfer to a SCIU without comorbid trauma (p < 0.01) but higher ICISS (p < 0.001), cervical injury (p < 0.01), and transferred by air-ambulance (p < 0.01). Indirect transfer to SCIU was more likely with two or more additional traumatic injuries (p < 0.01) or incomplete injury (p < 0.01). Patients not admitted to SCIU at all were older (p = 0.05) with lower levels of injury (p < 0.01). Direct transfers received earlier operative intervention (median (IQR) 12.9(7.9) hours), compared with patients transferred indirectly to SCIU (median (IQR) 19.5(18.9) hours), and had lower risk of complications (OR 3.2 v 1.4, p < 0.001). Complications included pressure injury, deep vein thrombosis, urinary infection, among others.
Getting patients with acute TSCI patients to the right place at the right time is dependent on numerous factors; some are still being triaged directly to non-trauma services which delays specialist and surgical care and increases complication risks. The higher rates of complication following delayed transfer to a SCIU should motivate health service policy makers to investigate reasons for this practice and consent to improvement strategies. More stringent adherence to recommended guidelines would prioritise direct SCIU transfer for patients injured within 60 min radius, enabling the benefits of specialised care.
及时治疗对于创伤性脊髓损伤(TSCI)后获得最佳治疗效果至关重要,建议在受伤后24小时内迅速转至专业脊髓损伤治疗单元(SCIU)。新南威尔士州(NSW)此前的研究发现,只有57%的TSCI患者因伤后急性期护理被收治到SCIU;73%的患者在受伤后24小时内完成了转运。我们评估了院前和院间转运情况,以更好地了解伤后护理路径对患者治疗效果的影响,并突出卫生服务路径中可能受益于改进的领域。
这项记录链接研究纳入了从新南威尔士州卫生记录链接中心获取的院前(救护车)、住院(入院患者)行政数据和费用数据。纳入了新南威尔士州所有年龄≥16岁的新发TSCI患者(2013 - 2016年)。我们使用地理空间方法调查了地理差异对从受伤地点进行院前和院间转运决策的影响。评估的结果包括到达SCIU的时间、手术情况以及这些变量对住院并发症发生情况的影响。
纳入标准确定了316例患者,地理空间分析显示,超过一半(53%,n = 168)的患者在距离SCIU 60分钟车程内受伤,但只有28.6%(n = 48)的患者被直接转运至SCIU。患者若无合并创伤(p < 0.01)、ICISS较高(p < 0.001)、颈椎损伤(p < 0.01)且通过空中救护车转运(p < 0.01),则更有可能被直接转运至SCIU。若有两处或更多其他创伤性损伤(p < 0.01)或不完全损伤(p < 0.01),则更有可能间接转运至SCIU。根本未被收治到SCIU的患者年龄较大(p = 0.05)且损伤程度较低(p < 0.01)。与间接转运至SCIU的患者相比,直接转运的患者接受了更早的手术干预(中位数(四分位间距)12.9(7.9)小时),且并发症风险较低(比值比3.2对1.4,p < 0.001)。并发症包括压疮、深静脉血栓形成、泌尿系统感染等。
让急性TSCI患者在正确的时间到达正确的地点取决于众多因素;一些患者仍被直接分诊到非创伤科室,这延误了专科和手术治疗,并增加了并发症风险。延迟转运至SCIU后并发症发生率较高,这应促使卫生服务政策制定者调查这种做法的原因并同意改进策略。更严格地遵守推荐指南将优先考虑将半径60分钟内受伤的患者直接转运至SCIU,从而实现专科护理的益处。