Gransjøen Ann M, Thorsen Kjetil, Lysdahl Kristin B, Wiig Siri, Hofmann Bjørn M
Department of Health Sciences, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Gjøvik, Norway.
The Norwegian Air Ambulance Foundation, Oslo, Norway.
Acta Radiol Open. 2021 Mar 17;10(3):2058460120988171. doi: 10.1177/2058460120988171. eCollection 2021 Mar.
An ever-increasing technological development in the field of radiology urges a need for guidelines to provide predictable and just health services. A musculoskeletal guideline was developed in Norway in 2014, without active implementation.
To investigate the impact of active guideline implementation on the use of musculoskeletal diagnostic imaging most frequently encountered in general practice (pain in the neck, shoulders, lower back, and knees).
The total number of outpatient radiological examinations across modalities registered at the Norwegian Health Economics Administration between January 2013 and February 2019 was assessed using an interrupted time series design.
A 12% reduction in the total examination of Magnetic Resonance Imaging shoulder and knee, and x-ray lower back and shoulder was found at a significant level ( = 0.05). Stratified analysis (Magnetic Resonance Imaging examination as one group and x-ray examinations as the other) showed that this reduction mainly was due to the reduction in the use of Magnetic Resonance Imaging examinations (shoulder and knee) which was reduced by 24% at a significant level ( = 0.002), while x-ray examinations had no significant level change ( = 0.71). No other statistically significant changes were found.
The impact of the implementation on the use of imaging of the neck, shoulder, lower back, and knee is uncertain. Significant reductions were demonstrated in the use of some examinations in the intervention county, but similar effects were not seen when including a control group in the analysis. This indicates a diffusion of the implementation, or other interventions or events that affected both counties and occurred in the intervention period.
放射学领域技术发展日新月异,因此迫切需要制定指南,以提供可预测且公正的医疗服务。挪威于2014年制定了肌肉骨骼指南,但未积极实施。
探讨积极实施指南对全科医疗中最常遇到的肌肉骨骼诊断成像(颈部、肩部、下背部和膝盖疼痛)使用情况的影响。
采用中断时间序列设计,评估了2013年1月至2019年2月挪威卫生经济管理局登记的各模态门诊放射学检查总数。
发现磁共振成像肩部和膝盖以及X光下背部和肩部的总检查量显著减少了12%(P = 0.05)。分层分析(磁共振成像检查为一组,X光检查为另一组)表明,这种减少主要是由于磁共振成像检查(肩部和膝盖)的使用减少,显著减少了24%(P = 0.002),而X光检查没有显著变化(P = 0.71)。未发现其他具有统计学意义的变化。
实施对颈部、肩部、下背部和膝盖成像使用的影响尚不确定。干预县某些检查的使用量显著减少,但分析中纳入对照组时未观察到类似效果。这表明实施存在扩散,或存在影响两个县且在干预期发生的其他干预措施或事件。