Ganis Laura, Christides Tatiana
Barts Health NHS Trust, London E1 1BB, UK.
Leicester Medical School, University of Leicester, Leicester LE1 7HA, UK.
Nutrients. 2021 Mar 16;13(3):957. doi: 10.3390/nu13030957.
Suboptimal nutrition is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in the United Kingdom (UK). Although patients cite physicians as trusted information sources on diet and weight loss, studies suggest that the management of nutrition-related disorders is hindered by insufficient medical education and training. Objectives of this study were to: (1) Quantify nutrition-related learning objectives (NLOs) in UK postgraduate medical training curriculums and assess variation across specialties; (2) assess inclusion of nutrition-related modules; (3) assess the extent to which NLOs are knowledge-, skill-, or behaviour-based, and in which Good Medical Practice (GMP) Domain(s) they fall. 43 current postgraduate curriculums, approved by the General Medical Council (GMC) and representing a spectrum of patient-facing training pathways in the UK, were included. NLOs were identified using four keywords: 'nutrition', 'diet', 'obesity', and 'lifestyle'. Where a keyword was used in a titled section followed by a number of objectives, this was designated as a 'module'. Where possible, NLOs were coded with the information to address objective 3. A median of 15 NLOs (mean 24) were identified per curriculum. Eleven specialties (25.6%) had five or less NLOs identified, including General Practice. Surgical curriculums had a higher number of NLOs compared with medical (median 30 and 8.5, respectively), as well as a higher inclusion rate of nutrition-related modules (100% of curriculums versus 34.4%, respectively). 52.9% of NLOs were knowledge-based, 34.9% skill-based, and 12.2% behaviour-based. The most common GMP Domain assigned to NLOs was Domain 1: Knowledge, Skills and Performance (53.0%), followed by Domain 2: Safety and Quality (20.6%), 3: Communication, Partnership and Teamwork (18.7%), and 4: Maintaining Trust (7.7%). This study demonstrates considerable variability in the number of nutrition-related learning objectives in UK postgraduate medical training. As insufficient nutrition education and training may underlie inadequate doctor-patient discussions, the results of this analysis suggest a need for further evaluation of nutrition-related competencies in postgraduate training.
在英国,营养状况欠佳是发病和死亡的主要原因。尽管患者将医生视为饮食和减肥方面值得信赖的信息来源,但研究表明,营养相关疾病的管理因医学教育和培训不足而受到阻碍。本研究的目的是:(1) 量化英国研究生医学培训课程中与营养相关的学习目标 (NLO),并评估各专业之间的差异;(2) 评估营养相关模块的纳入情况;(3) 评估NLO基于知识、技能或行为的程度,以及它们属于《良好医疗实践》(GMP) 的哪个领域。本研究纳入了43份当前的研究生课程,这些课程均获得了英国医学总会 (GMC) 的批准,代表了英国一系列面向患者的培训途径。使用四个关键词确定NLO:“营养”、“饮食”、“肥胖”和“生活方式”。如果某个关键词出现在标题部分后面跟着一些目标,则将其指定为一个“模块”。在可能的情况下,NLO会用相关信息进行编码,以实现目标3。每份课程中确定的NLO中位数为15个(平均24个)。包括全科医学在内的11个专业 (25.6%) 确定的NLO为5个或更少。与医学专业相比,外科专业课程的NLO数量更多(中位数分别为30个和8.5个),营养相关模块的纳入率也更高(分别为100% 和34.4%)。52.9% 的NLO基于知识,34.9% 基于技能,12.2% 基于行为。分配给NLO最常见的GMP领域是领域1:知识、技能和表现 (53.0%),其次是领域2:安全与质量 (20.6%)、领域3:沟通、合作与团队合作 (18.7%) 和领域4:维持信任 (7.7%)。本研究表明,英国研究生医学培训中与营养相关学习目标的数量存在很大差异。由于营养教育和培训不足可能是医患讨论不充分的原因,本分析结果表明需要对研究生培训中与营养相关的能力进行进一步评估。