Kamin Tanja, Čož Sinja, Atanasova Sara
University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Social Sciences, Kardeljeva ploscad 5, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Zdr Varst. 2021 Mar 18;60(2):105-113. doi: 10.2478/sjph-2021-0016. eCollection 2021 Jun.
Alcohol consumption among young people is strongly related to alcohol availability. The minimum legal drinking (purchasing) age (MLDA) is a legal measure that regulates alcohol availability to minors in Slovenia. This study examines (1) retailers' compliance with the MLDA law in Slovenia and (2) the effectiveness of two interventions directed at cashiers in off-premise stores.
The study uses a non-randomized quasi-experimental design to evaluate the effectiveness of (1) a communication intervention directed at off-premise store managers, and (2) an intervention by the Slovene Market Inspectorate. The first intervention focused on informing cashiers about MLDA's importance and their role as gatekeepers of young people's health, while the second involved law enforcement. Using the mystery shopping protocol, we conducted two waves of purchase attempts with decoy underage shoppers pre- and post-intervention in 97 off-premise stores. We collected data on the shopping process at the point of sale and conducted 40 semistructured interviews with cashiers to evaluate the barriers and incentives regarding MLDA compliance.
Retailers' initial noncompliance rate with MLDA in off-premise stores was high, but improved significantly after the law enforcement intervention. We identified a significant correlation between the cashiers' ID requests and the refusal of alcohol sales, but cashiers' ID requests remained low. Qualitative findings reveal that cashiers experience several issues when handling MLDA in practice.
Noncompliance with MLDA persisted even after the law enforcement intervention, revealing the need for policy makers to introduce new strategies for MLDA enforcement, such as revocable alcohol licenses for off-premise stores.
年轻人饮酒与酒精的可得性密切相关。法定最低饮酒(购买)年龄(MLDA)是斯洛文尼亚一项规范未成年人酒精可得性的法律措施。本研究考察了(1)斯洛文尼亚零售商对MLDA法律的遵守情况,以及(2)针对非店内商店收银员的两种干预措施的有效性。
本研究采用非随机准实验设计来评估(1)针对非店内商店经理的沟通干预措施,以及(2)斯洛文尼亚市场监管机构的干预措施的有效性。第一种干预措施侧重于告知收银员MLDA的重要性以及他们作为年轻人健康守门人的角色,而第二种干预措施涉及执法。我们使用神秘顾客协议,在干预前后对97家非店内商店进行了两轮诱饵未成年购物者的购买尝试。我们收集了销售点购物过程的数据,并对收银员进行了40次半结构化访谈,以评估遵守MLDA的障碍和激励因素。
非店内商店零售商最初对MLDA的不遵守率很高,但在执法干预后有了显著改善。我们发现收银员要求出示身份证件与拒绝销售酒精之间存在显著相关性,但收银员要求出示身份证件的情况仍然很少。定性研究结果表明,收银员在实际处理MLDA时遇到了几个问题。
即使在执法干预之后,对MLDA的不遵守情况仍然存在,这表明政策制定者需要引入新的MLDA执法策略,例如对非店内商店发放可撤销的酒类销售许可证。