Zhang Kaihua, Balduf Ty, Caricato Marco
Department of Chemistry, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA.
Chirality. 2021 Jun;33(6):303-314. doi: 10.1002/chir.23310. Epub 2021 Apr 7.
This work presents the first simulations of the full optical rotation (OR) tensor at coupled cluster with single and double excitations (CCSD) level in the modified velocity gauge (MVG) formalism. The CCSD-MVG OR tensor is origin independent, and each tensor element can in principle be related directly to experimental measurements on oriented systems. We compare the CCSD results with those from two density functionals, B3LYP and CAM-B3LYP, on a test set of 22 chiral molecules. The results show that the functionals consistently overestimate the CCSD results for the individual tensor components and for the trace (which is related to the isotropic OR), by 10%-20% with CAM-B3LYP and 20%-30% with B3LYP. The data show that the contribution of the electric dipole-magnetic dipole polarizability tensor to the OR tensor is on average twice as large as that of the electric dipole-electric quadrupole polarizability tensor. The difficult case of (1S,4S)-(-)-norbornenone also reveals that the evaluation of the former polarizability tensor is more sensitive than the latter. We attribute the better agreement of CAM-B3LYP with CCSD to the ability of this functional to better reproduce electron delocalization compared with B3LYP, consistent with previous reports on isotropic OR. The CCSD-MVG approach allows the computation of reference data of the full OR tensor, which may be used to test more computationally efficient approximate methods that can be employed to study realistic models of optically active materials.
这项工作展示了在修正速度规范(MVG)形式体系下,首次在耦合簇单双激发(CCSD)水平对全旋光(OR)张量进行的模拟。CCSD - MVG的OR张量与原点无关,原则上每个张量元素都可直接与取向体系的实验测量相关联。我们在22个手性分子的测试集上,将CCSD结果与两种密度泛函B3LYP和CAM - B3LYP的结果进行了比较。结果表明,对于各个张量分量以及迹(与各向同性OR相关),这些泛函始终高估CCSD结果,CAM - B3LYP高估10% - 20%,B3LYP高估20% - 30%。数据表明,电偶极 - 磁偶极极化率张量对OR张量的贡献平均是电偶极 - 电四极极化率张量贡献的两倍。(1S,4S)-(-)-降冰片烯酮这个复杂例子还表明,前一种极化率张量的评估比后一种更敏感。我们将CAM - B3LYP与CCSD更好的一致性归因于该泛函与B3LYP相比,能够更好地重现电子离域,这与之前关于各向同性OR的报道一致。CCSD - MVG方法允许计算全OR张量的参考数据,可用于测试计算效率更高的近似方法,这些方法可用于研究旋光材料的实际模型。