Post-Graduation Program in Dentistry, Federal University of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil.
Dental School, Federal University of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil.
Int J Dent Hyg. 2022 Feb;20(1):167-181. doi: 10.1111/idh.12497. Epub 2021 Apr 14.
To review the scientific literature and identify dental plaque control strategies focussed on elderly people that improve plaque indices.
Scoping review (Joanna Briggs protocol).
Individual search strategies developed for six databases. The selection of the manuscripts in two phases: title and abstract review, and complete review.
Studies on interventions for plaque control in elderly people (60y+). Epidemiological studies and those focussed on caregivers, health professionals and periodontal maintenance therapies were excluded.
The initial search yielded 2803 studies, 26 were included. The results were classified into: exclusively chemical (10), educational (9), exclusively mechanical (6), and combined mechanical and chemical (1). The studies reported different types of interventions: sugarless chewing gum, chlorhexidine (CHX) in different preparations and concentrations, mouthwash based on essential oils, stannous/sodium fluoride dentifrice and lactoferrin/lactoperoxidase tablets. Additionally, conventional and alternative toothbrushes and professional brushing were tested. Educational interventions included oral hygiene guidance, verbal information, and demonstrations of dental and denture cleaning procedures, and lifestyle changes. Many studies have reported strategies that improve dental plaque indices but without statistical significance when compared to control groups. Promising results were found with the use of CHX, sugarless chewing gum, professional brushing and educational strategies with demonstration, but the results were not long-lasting.
The literature reports that mechanical, chemical and educational strategies have some efficacy in dental plaque control in the elderly population. The results should be viewed with caution, considering the type of intervention (isolated or combined) and the maintenance of the results obtained.
回顾科学文献,确定以改善菌斑指数为目标的老年人口腔菌斑控制策略。
范围综述(乔安娜·布里格斯方案)。
针对六个数据库制定的个体化检索策略。分两个阶段对文献进行选择:标题和摘要审查,以及全文审查。
针对老年人(≥60 岁)菌斑控制的干预措施研究。排除了流行病学研究以及针对照护者、卫生专业人员和牙周维护治疗的研究。
最初的检索得到 2803 篇研究,纳入 26 篇。结果分类为:纯化学制剂(10 篇)、教育(9 篇)、纯机械(6 篇)和机械联合化学制剂(1 篇)。研究报告了不同类型的干预措施:无糖口香糖、不同制剂和浓度的洗必泰(CHX)、基于精油的漱口液、含锡/氟化钠牙膏和乳铁蛋白/乳过氧化物酶片。此外,还测试了常规和替代牙刷以及专业刷牙。教育干预包括口腔卫生指导、口头信息以及口腔和义齿清洁程序的演示,以及生活方式的改变。许多研究报告了改善牙菌斑指数的策略,但与对照组相比,无统计学意义。使用 CHX、无糖口香糖、专业刷牙和有演示的教育策略显示出有希望的结果,但效果并不持久。
文献报告表明,机械、化学和教育策略在老年人群体的口腔菌斑控制中具有一定的效果。考虑到干预类型(单独或联合)和获得的结果的维持,结果应谨慎看待。