Department of Population, Family, & Reproductive Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, 615 N Wolfe Street, Baltimore, MD, U21201, USA.
Prev Sci. 2021 Jul;22(5):633-644. doi: 10.1007/s11121-021-01232-9. Epub 2021 Apr 9.
Maternal risks such as poor mental health, partner violence, and substance misuse can undermine child health and development. Maternal and early childhood home visiting programs address these risks primarily through referral and coordination with community-based services, yet effects on these outcomes have been small. This study assessed the strengths of local home visiting sites' systems to support coordination of mental health, partner violence, and substance use services. Investigators recruited home visiting sites (N = 88) representing diverse models from a national practice-based research network, the Home Visiting Applied Research Collaborative (HARC). Web-based surveys assessed five implementation system supports for coordination and nine coordination activities drawn from the Measurement Framework for Coordination developed earlier in the project. Surveys also assessed seven coordination barriers identified in previous research. Sites varied in their implementation supports and coordination activities; on average, sites had stronger systems in place to support screening and referring families than to support linkage and follow-up. Implementation supports and activity scores were higher for mental health and partner violence than for substance use. Across all service needs, scores were highest for offering a referral and documenting the caregiver's agreement for exchange of information between providers. Scores were lowest for offering a warm handoff. Lack of open slots and lack of transportation were major barriers to successful coordination for all three services. Results suggest that home visiting coordination could be strengthened by focusing on infrastructure for linkage and follow-up with services in the broader system of care.
母亲面临的风险,如心理健康状况不佳、伴侣暴力和物质滥用,可能会损害儿童的健康和发育。母婴和儿童早期家访项目主要通过转介和与社区服务协调来应对这些风险,但这些干预措施对这些结果的影响很小。本研究评估了当地家访点支持协调心理健康、伴侣暴力和物质使用服务的系统的优势。调查人员从全国实践为基础的研究网络“家访应用研究合作组织”(HARC)中招募了代表不同模式的家访点(N=88)。基于网络的调查评估了五个实施系统支持,用于协调和从项目早期开发的协调衡量框架中抽取的九个协调活动。调查还评估了之前研究中确定的七个协调障碍。各家访点在实施支持和协调活动方面存在差异;平均而言,各家访点在支持家庭筛查和转介方面的系统要强于支持联系和后续服务。在心理健康和伴侣暴力方面,实施支持和活动得分高于物质使用。在所有服务需求中,提供转介并记录照顾者之间提供者信息交换的同意的得分最高。提供温暖转介的得分最低。对于所有三种服务,缺乏开放名额和缺乏交通工具是成功协调的主要障碍。研究结果表明,通过关注与更广泛的护理系统中的服务的联系和后续服务的基础设施,家访协调可以得到加强。