Weil Yoram A, Bernstein Brian P, Maqungo Sithombo, Khoury Amal, Liebergall Meir, Laubscher Maritz
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Hadassah Hebrew University Hospital, Jerusalem, Israel.
Orthopaedic Research Unit, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Groote Schuur Hospital, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
OTA Int. 2020 Mar 23;3(1):e065. doi: 10.1097/OI9.0000000000000065. eCollection 2020 Mar.
Despite the same latitude on earth, Israel and South Africa have a wide variety of healthcare systems and approaches. Israel is a developed country with life expectancy within the first decile of the modern world. South Africa is a developing country where available resources and health care varies greatly across the country. Israeli policy makers have realized in 1999 the importance of early surgery for hip fractures as the single most important factor contributing to decreased mortality. After an introduction of a newer reimbursement system in 2004, and public advertising of early hip fracture treatment as a quality tag for hospitals, in more than 85% of the cases patients are operated on early (within 8 hours) with a significant decrease in mortality. However, other issues such as patient preparation, rehabilitation, and prevention are still at their beginning. South Africa deals with significant challenges with high energy hip fractures in a younger population, although osteoporosis is on the rise in certain parts of the country. Due to limited resources and distances, time to surgery differs among hospital systems in the country. In public hospitals, a delay up to a week may be common, whereas in private hospitals most patients are operated early within 48 to 72 hours. Due to decreased life expectancy, arthroplasty is more aggressively used in displaced femoral neck fractures. Rehabilitation is mostly done within the families. Prevention and orthogeriatric teamwork are not being commonly practiced. Generally speaking, more attention to hip fractures is needed from healthcare funders.
尽管以色列和南非处于地球上相同的纬度,但它们有着各种各样的医疗保健系统和方法。以色列是一个发达国家,其预期寿命处于现代世界的前十分之一。南非是一个发展中国家,全国可用资源和医疗保健差异很大。以色列政策制定者在1999年认识到髋部骨折早期手术的重要性,这是导致死亡率下降的最重要单一因素。2004年引入新的报销系统,并将髋部骨折早期治疗作为医院质量标签进行公开宣传后,超过85%的病例患者接受了早期手术(8小时内),死亡率显著下降。然而,患者准备、康复和预防等其他问题仍处于起步阶段。南非在年轻人群体中处理高能髋部骨折面临重大挑战,尽管该国某些地区骨质疏松症正在上升。由于资源有限和距离问题,该国不同医院系统的手术时间存在差异。在公立医院,延迟一周可能很常见,而在私立医院,大多数患者在48至72小时内接受早期手术。由于预期寿命下降,人工关节置换术在移位型股骨颈骨折中使用更为积极。康复大多在家庭内部进行。预防和骨科老年医学团队合作并不常见。总体而言,医疗保健资助者需要更多关注髋部骨折问题。