Narisada Atsushi, Badawy Philip J, Schieman Scott
Department of Sociology, Saint Mary's University, 923 Robie Street, Halifax, NS B3H 3C3 Canada.
University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Soc Justice Res. 2021;34(2):146-172. doi: 10.1007/s11211-021-00365-0. Epub 2021 Apr 8.
People value being paid appropriately for their work-but national surveys indicate that many working adults report a discrepancy between what they actually earn and what they think they should justly earn. This evidence provides an impetus for examining the factors that shape workers' justice perceptions of earnings. The present study elaborates on two key distributive justice principles-equity and need-that guide people's ideas about their just reward. We ask: How do contemporary workers experience and understand the nature of work effort and need? We employ a mixed methods research design to answer this question. First, we analyze focus group interviews among workers in Toronto, Ontario ( = 22), and generate two novel hypotheses about the factors that shape workers' expectation for greater rewards: "downloaded" and "sideloaded" extra work that induce feelings of overwork, and rising cost of living and the associated financial strain. Second, drawing upon focus group narratives, we operationalize these concepts and test our hypotheses with a 2019 nationally representative sample of Canadian workers ( = 2,111). The results show that downloaded and sideloaded extra work shape greater reward expectations partly through the sense of overload, and rising cost of living and the associated financial strain also shape reward expectations. Furthermore, financial strain amplifies the link between extra work and greater reward expectations. We situate these findings within a broader discussion of the nature of effort and need among contemporary workers and its implications for justice perceptions.
人们重视自己的工作能得到适当报酬,但全国性调查表明,许多在职成年人表示,他们的实际收入与他们认为自己应得的合理收入之间存在差异。这一证据为研究影响工人收入公平感的因素提供了动力。本研究详细阐述了指导人们公正报酬观念的两个关键分配正义原则——公平和需求。我们提出问题:当代工人如何体验和理解工作努力和需求的本质?我们采用混合方法研究设计来回答这个问题。首先,我们分析了安大略省多伦多市22名工人的焦点小组访谈,并就影响工人对更高报酬期望的因素提出了两个新假设:导致过度劳累感的“附加”和“额外”额外工作,以及生活成本上升和相关的经济压力。其次,根据焦点小组的叙述,我们对这些概念进行了操作化,并使用2019年具有全国代表性的加拿大工人样本(n = 2111)对我们的假设进行了检验。结果表明,附加和额外的额外工作部分通过过载感形成了更高的报酬期望,生活成本上升和相关的经济压力也影响了报酬期望。此外,经济压力放大了额外工作与更高报酬期望之间的联系。我们将这些发现置于对当代工人努力和需求本质及其对公平感影响的更广泛讨论之中。