Ho Owen Tsung Wen, Ng Winston Cheng Ann, Ow Zachariah Gene Wing, Ho Yeung Jek, Lim Wen Hui, Yong Jie Ning, Wang Renaeta Shiqi, Wong Keng Lin, Ng Cheng Han, Muthiah Mark D, Teo Claire Min-Li
Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
Department of Orthopedics Surgery, Sengkang General Hospital, Singapore, Singapore.
Transpl Int. 2021 Aug;34(8):1386-1396. doi: 10.1111/tri.13887. Epub 2021 Jul 1.
To investigate the efficacy of bisphosphonates and compare oral and IV formulations on bone mineral density (BMD) and fracture incidence in post-orthotopic liver transplant (OLT) patients. Electronic databases were searched, and six RCTs and three cohort studies were included out of 711 articles. Main outcomes included post-OLT BMD changes, fracture incidence, and treatment adverse reactions. Pairwise meta-analysis was conducted for binary and continuous outcomes, while pooled fracture incidence utilized single-arm meta-analysis. Post-OLT fracture incidence was reported in nine studies (n = 591). Total fracture incidence was 6.6% (CI: 3.4-12.4%) in bisphosphonate group and 19.1% (CI: 14.3-25.1%) in calcium and vitamin D group. Total fractures were significantly lower in patients on bisphosphonate, compared to calcium and vitamin D (n = 591; OR = 0.037; CI: 0.18-0.77; P = 0.008). Overall fractures were significantly lower in the oral group (n = 263; OR = 0.26; CI: 0.08-0.85; P = 0.02) but not in the IV group (n = 328; OR = 0.45; CI: 0.16-1.26; P = 0.129). Both oral and IV bisphosphonates are effective in reducing fracture incidence post-OLT compared to calcium and vitamin D. Oral formulations may also have an advantage over IV in reducing bone loss and fracture incidence post-OLT.
为研究双膦酸盐的疗效,并比较口服和静脉注射剂型对原位肝移植(OLT)术后患者骨密度(BMD)和骨折发生率的影响。检索了电子数据库,在711篇文章中纳入了6项随机对照试验(RCT)和3项队列研究。主要结局包括OLT术后BMD变化、骨折发生率和治疗不良反应。对二元和连续性结局进行了成对荟萃分析,而汇总骨折发生率采用单臂荟萃分析。9项研究(n = 591)报告了OLT术后骨折发生率。双膦酸盐组的总骨折发生率为6.6%(CI:3.4 - 12.4%),钙和维生素D组为19.1%(CI:14.3 - 25.1%)。与钙和维生素D相比,服用双膦酸盐的患者总骨折发生率显著更低(n = 591;OR = 0.037;CI:0.18 - 0.77;P = 0.008)。口服组的总体骨折发生率显著更低(n = 263;OR = 0.26;CI:0.08 - 0.85;P = 0.02),但静脉注射组并非如此(n = 328;OR = 0.45;CI:0.16 - 1.26;P = 0.129)。与钙和维生素D相比,口服和静脉注射双膦酸盐在降低OLT术后骨折发生率方面均有效。口服剂型在减少OLT术后骨质流失和骨折发生率方面可能也比静脉注射剂型更具优势。