From the Department of Neurology (L.P., Z.C., M.L., L.L., H.P., Y.S., Y.P., Q.D., S.W., G.Z., L.W., H.Y., L.H., Y.X., Z.T., N.W., Y.G., X.H., L.S., J.L., B.T., H.J.), Department of Pathology (C.W.), National Clinical Research Center for Geriatric Disorders (Z.C., L.S., B.T., H.J.), Xiangya Hospital, Central South University; Department of Neurology (Z.L.), The Second Xiangya Hospital, Central South University; Key Laboratory of Hunan Province in Neurodegenerative Disorders (Z.C., L.S., J.L., B.T., H.J.), Center for Medical Genetics School of Life Sciences (K.X., J.L., C.C.), Hunan Key Laboratory of Medical Genetics (K.X., J.L., C.C.), School of Computer Science and Engineering (R.Q.), and School of Basic Medical Science (H.J.), Central South University, Changsha, Hunan, China; Department of Neurology (T.K.), University of Bonn; and German Center for Neurodegenerative Diseases (DZNE) (T.K.), Bonn, Germany.
Neurology. 2021 Jun 8;96(23):e2885-e2895. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000012068. Epub 2021 Apr 23.
The aim of this study was to develop an appropriate parametric survival model to predict patient's age at onset (AAO) for spinocerebellar ataxia type 3/Machado-Joseph disease (SCA3/MJD) populations from mainland China.
We compared the efficiency and performance of 6 parametric survival analysis methods (exponential, weibull, log-gaussian, gaussian, log-logistic, and logistic) based on cytosine-adenine-guanine (CAG) repeat length at to predict the probability of AAO in the largest cohort of patients with SCA3/MJD. A set of evaluation criteria, including -2 log-likelihood statistic, Akaike information criterion (AIC), bayesian information criterion (BIC), Nagelkerke R-squared (Nagelkerke R^2), and Cox-Snell residual plot, were used to identify the best model.
Among these 6 parametric survival models, the logistic model had the lowest -2 log-likelihood (6,560.12), AIC (6,566.12), and BIC (6,566.14) and the highest value of Nagelkerke R^2 (0.54), with the closest graph to the bisector Cox-Snell residual graph. Therefore, the logistic survival model was the best fit to the studied data. Using the optimal logistic survival model, we indicated the age-specific probability distribution of AAO according to the CAG repeat size and current age.
We first demonstrated that the logistic survival model provided the best fit for AAO prediction in patients with SCA3/MJD from mainland China. This optimal model can be valuable in clinical and research. However, the rigorous clinical testing and practice of other independent cohorts are needed for its clinical application. A unified model across multiethnic cohorts is worth further exploration by identifying regional differences and significant modifiers in AAO determination.
本研究旨在开发一种合适的参数生存模型,以预测中国大陆人群中脊髓小脑性共济失调 3 型/马查多-约瑟夫病(SCA3/MJD)患者的发病年龄(AAO)。
我们比较了 6 种参数生存分析方法(指数、威布尔、对数正态、正态、对数逻辑和逻辑)的效率和性能,基于胞嘧啶-腺嘌呤-鸟嘌呤(CAG)重复长度预测最大 SCA3/MJD 患者队列中 AAO 的概率。使用一套评估标准,包括 -2 对数似然统计量、赤池信息量准则(AIC)、贝叶斯信息量准则(BIC)、奈格尔克准则 R 平方(Nagelkerke R^2)和 Cox-Snell 残差图,来确定最佳模型。
在这 6 种参数生存模型中,逻辑模型的 -2 对数似然(6,560.12)、AIC(6,566.12)和 BIC(6,566.14)最低,Nagelkerke R^2(0.54)最高,Cox-Snell 残差图最接近平分线。因此,逻辑生存模型最适合研究数据。使用最优逻辑生存模型,我们根据 CAG 重复大小和当前年龄给出了 AAO 的年龄特异性概率分布。
我们首次证明,逻辑生存模型为中国大陆 SCA3/MJD 患者的 AAO 预测提供了最佳拟合。该最优模型在临床和研究中具有重要价值。然而,需要对其他独立队列进行严格的临床测试和实践,以将其应用于临床。通过确定 AAO 确定中的区域差异和显著修饰剂,跨多民族队列的统一模型值得进一步探索。