Great Lakes Institute of Environmental Research, University of Windsor, 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, Ontario N9B 3P4, Canada.
School of the Environment and Great Lakes Institute of Environmental Research, University of Windsor, 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, Ontario N9B 3P4, Canada.
Sci Total Environ. 2021 Aug 25;784:147188. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.147188. Epub 2021 Apr 19.
In-situ nutrient analysers are a promising tool for improving the temporal resolution of data and filling knowledge gaps in drivers of harmful algal blooms. There are significant challenges however regarding instrument biofouling and data drift, which remain largely unquantified and unresolved. In this study the effects of biofouling on data consistency and accuracy is quantified on automated wet chemical analysers during long-term monitoring. In 2019 three fractions of phosphorus (P); total phosphorus (TP), total dissolved phosphorus (TDP) and soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP), were measured in-situ at four sites in Southern Ontario, Canada. The analysers were exposed to a wide range of P concentrations and biofouling extremes over an 8-month period. They were calibrated using chemical standards both in the field and the lab, and validated with fortnightly grab samples, and the representativeness of real-time data under a range of biofouling conditions were analysed. Results show that analysers biofouling during long-term deployment can desensitize instrument measurements, with greatest impacts on instruments operating in highly turbid environments. Temporal changes in calibration curves suggest that equilibrium P concentrations (EPC) of sediments accumulating inside filters can elicit a rapid exchange of dissolved P (SRP, TDP) with the water sample. Data drift increases the further from the EPC an instrument is required to analyse, and thus this study demonstrates that for in-situ P monitoring, unless filters are frequently replaced or renovated, in-situ probes should ideally be dedicated to a specific waterbody type defined by similar EPC values. It is recommended that in order to ensure accuracy in in-situ monitoring of TP, TDP and SRP during long-term deployment, preliminary site trials should be conducted to ascertain sediment EPC; the extent of biofouling should be monitored; and/or frequent grab samples taken for post-deployment validation. The findings apply to any in-situ phosphorus monitoring techniques for SRP or TDP.
原位营养分析器是提高数据时间分辨率和填补有害藻华驱动因素知识空白的有前途的工具。然而,仪器生物污垢和数据漂移仍然存在很大的挑战,这些问题在很大程度上尚未得到量化和解决。在这项研究中,量化了生物污垢对长期监测期间自动化学分析仪数据一致性和准确性的影响。2019 年,在加拿大安大略省南部的四个地点原位测量了磷的三个分数(P);总磷(TP)、总溶解磷(TDP)和可溶解反应磷(SRP)。这些分析仪在 8 个月的时间内暴露在广泛的 P 浓度和生物污垢极端条件下。它们使用现场和实验室中的化学标准进行校准,并与每两周的抓样进行验证,分析了在一系列生物污垢条件下实时数据的代表性。结果表明,长期部署期间分析仪的生物污垢会使仪器测量变得不敏感,对在高浑浊环境中运行的仪器影响最大。校准曲线的时间变化表明,沉积物中积累的平衡磷浓度(EPC)可以引起水中可溶解磷(SRP、TDP)与水样的快速交换。数据漂移随着仪器需要分析的 EPC 越来越远而增加,因此本研究表明,对于原位 P 监测,除非频繁更换或翻新过滤器,否则理想情况下,原位探头应专门用于由类似 EPC 值定义的特定水体类型。建议为了确保在长期部署期间原位监测 TP、TDP 和 SRP 的准确性,应进行初步现场试验以确定沉积物 EPC;应监测生物污垢的程度;并/或在部署后频繁采取抓样进行验证。这些发现适用于任何用于 SRP 或 TDP 的原位磷监测技术。