Kim Jinho
Department of Sociology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1180 Observatory Drive, Madison, WI 53706.
Youth Soc. 2020 Apr 1;52(3):377-402. doi: 10.1177/0044118x18781641. Epub 2018 Jun 14.
Given large variations in the etiology and developmental trajectories of violent and nonviolent delinquency, this study examines whether educational outcomes of violent and nonviolent offenders might differ. In particular, this study attempts to remove environmental influences such as family background and neighborhood effects from the effects of delinquency because these factors are likely to differentially confound the effects of violent and nonviolent delinquency on educational attainment. By exploiting variation within sibling pairs, this study finds that the effects of engagement in violent delinquency on education is driven spuriously by shared family background, whereas the effects of nonviolent delinquency are quite robust to adjustment for family fixed effects. Moreover, relying on fixed effects estimates, this study finds that the effects of engagement in nonviolent delinquent activity on educational attainment occur in part through disruption of educational progress, rather than through institutional responses to student delinquency and social-psychological processes.
鉴于暴力犯罪和非暴力犯罪在病因及发展轨迹上存在巨大差异,本研究探讨暴力犯罪者和非暴力犯罪者的教育成果是否可能有所不同。具体而言,本研究试图从犯罪影响中去除诸如家庭背景和邻里效应等环境影响,因为这些因素可能会以不同方式混淆暴力犯罪和非暴力犯罪对教育成就的影响。通过利用兄弟姐妹对之间的差异,本研究发现,参与暴力犯罪对教育的影响是由共享的家庭背景虚假驱动的,而非暴力犯罪的影响在调整家庭固定效应后相当稳健。此外,基于固定效应估计,本研究发现,参与非暴力犯罪活动对教育成就的影响部分是通过扰乱教育进程产生的,而不是通过学校对学生犯罪的反应和社会心理过程产生的。